CRIME

Daybell lawyer asks to drop charges, prosecution files to combine trials

Sep 3, 2020, 11:00 AM | Updated: Sep 4, 2020, 10:33 am

ST. ANTHONY, Idaho — Two separate motions filed in Idaho Court over the last week are looking to change the way the felony trials for both Chad and Lori Daybell will proceed. 

In one motion filed by Chad Daybell’s attorney, John Prior, last week asked the State of Idaho to dismiss all charges against him, saying the prosecution provided insufficient evidence during their preliminary hearing in early August.

And, on Monday, state prosecutors asked that both cases against the Daybells be combined, arguing their evidence against the two are nearly identical.

Motion to dismiss charges

In two motions filed on Thursday, Chad Daybell’s defense attorney, John Prior, requested more time for a hearing, citing a “lack of sufficient evidence” presented against his client.

“The charges are not supported by the evidence and duplicative as allegations against the defendant. Further, the prosecution has yet to present evidence to support when the alleged acts is supposedly to have taken place.”

Prior says that the prosecution’s assertions were “vague and overly broad” and as such violate Daybell’s constitutional right to be “fairly notified and appraised of when, how, and what he is accused of doing.”

In a separate motion, Prior also requested that the 14-day deadline for a hearing on his request to have charges dropped. be extended because his office had not received a transcript of the preliminary hearing or evidence as part of the court’s discovery.

Motion to combine trials

In another motion filed by special prosecutor Rob Wood on Monday, he asks that both Chad Daybell and his wife Lori’s trials be combined, arguing that the evidence they have in both cases is nearly identical, and as such, the trials would also be nearly identical.

Chad Daybell pleaded not guilty of two felony counts of conspiracy to commit destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence, and two felony counts of destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence.

Lori Daybell’s arraignment is set for Thursday, September 10. She will enter a plea on two felony charges of conspiracy to commit destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence.

According to East Idaho News, “Under Idaho court procedures, co-defendants can be charged under the same complaint if they are accused of participating in the same act or acts of the alleged crimes.”


TIMELINE: Missing Idaho Kids


Wood argues in his memorandum: “the statements the Daybells (and Alex Cox) each made as co-conspirators in furtherance of the conspiracy are allowed as evidence against each of them and as such it promotes judicial economy and efficiency to have each defendant in the same trial while those statements are introduced…

“The evidence presented at Chad Daybell’s preliminary hearing, which will be expanded on at trial, established that the Daybells acted in concert to mislead law enforcement and others in regards to the location of the deceased children’s bodies. Judicial economy would require that the State not be required to try essentially identical cases of husband and wife acting as coconspirators twice.”

What’s next?

Lori Vallow Daybell is expected to be arraigned on Thursday on two felony charges of conspiracy to commit destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence.

Chad Daybell has already pleaded not guilty on two felony counts of conspiracy to commit destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence, and two felony counts of destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence. His jury trial is set to begin on January 11.


EXCLUSIVE: Satellite photo shows Chad Daybell property on likely day of child’s burial

Full transcript of Lori Daybell secret phone call recording

Transcript of Lori Daybell’s call to Chad Daybell on day of children’s discovery

Today’s Top Stories

Crime

winds may be to blame paraglider9-year-old boy taser swat dog dynamite evacuation shoplifter injury...
Mark Jones

Two teenagers taken into custody for allegedly firing a weapon at a vehicle

Two teenagers were taken into custody Friday night for allegedly firing gun shots at a vehicle in West Valley City.
1 day ago
NYPD officers are seen at the scene of shooting in Harlem  on Friday, Jan. 21, 2022, in New York. A...
The Associated Press

Official: 1 officer dead, 1 gravely hurt in Harlem shooting

Two New York police officers were shot Friday night after responding to a domestic disturbance call. One died and the other was gravely injured.
1 day ago
The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources is investigating the illegal killing of a buck deer earlier...
Mark Jones

DWR seeks information on killing of buck deer and removal of its antlers

DWR officers are investigating the illegal killing of a buck deer near the border of Sanpete and Sevier counties.
1 day ago
(Crystal Turner, left, and Kylen Schulte on a road trip in 2020. Photo posted to Instagram)...
Paul Nelson and Eliza Craig

Police now have persons of interest in Moab double murder case

Police say there are now persons of interest in the Moab double murder case.
1 day ago
Gabby Petito timeline...
Kira Hoffelmeyer and Becky Bruce

FBI says Brian Laundrie took responsibility for Gabby Petito’s murder

DENVER — The FBI says it’s close to closing the murder investigation of Gabby Petito after her fiancé claimed responsibility for her death before he died. “All logical investigative steps have been concluded in this case,” said FBI Denver Division Special Agent in Charge Michael Schneider. “The investigation did not identify any other individuals other […]
1 day ago
west high burglary...
Eliza Craig

A man has been arrested after breaking into West High School late at night

Police have a suspect in custody for a burglary at West High School. The overnight burglary is still being investigated.
1 day ago
Daybell lawyer asks to drop charges, prosecution files to combine trials