Google v. Oracle court case decided on ‘fair use’

Apr 6, 2021, 5:00 AM
Google headquarters in Mountain View, California, google oracle...
Google headquarters in Mountain View, California (Photo: Dan Bammes)
(Photo: Dan Bammes)

SALT LAKE CITY — A specialist in intellectual property law at the University of Utah law school says that after the supreme court’s decision Monday, on the Google versus Oracle case, it’s likely software developers will be more specific in the future when they tell users what they can and can’t do with their software. 

Google won the 6-2 decision based on the concept of fair use under copyright law.

“They’ll be careful to spell out in the documentation what you can and can’t do with those languages,” Contreras told KSL Newsradio.

The case grew out of Google’s use of the Java programming language to develop the Android operating system for mobile devices. Google lifted about 11,500 lines of computer code from the Java API, or application program interface. Java was developed by Sun Microsystems, which was acquired by Oracle.

Professor Contreras said the court decided the case on the basis of ‘fair use,’ a long-standing concept of copyright law.

“It’s 11,500 lines of code out of about 2.3 million,” Contreras said, “and so, in totality, it’s not actually, I think the court said it was 0.4% of the work.”

Fair use allows, among other things, a newspaper to quote a passage from a novel for purposes of comment and review, and there are other exceptions permitted by statute and case law.

The case between Google and Oracle has dragged on for about ten years, with billions of dollars at stake.


Other Reading:

Hey Google Home Speaker: wake me up to KSL NewsRadio

Study: Increased suicide risk for teen girls with heavy social media use

Gina Carano fired from ‘Mandalorian’ after social media post

Today’s Top Stories


electronic plane...
Jackie Wattles, CNN Business

United Airlines puts $10 million into plan to shuttle customers by electric aircraft

The United investment in California-based Archer could help the company get the first of its four-seater helicopters in operation by 2024.
4 days ago
driverless taxi...
Catherine Thorbecke, CNN Business

Tech giant gets permits for first fully driverless taxi service in China

In the U.S., robotaxi offerings remain extremely sparse and ridehailing giants like Uber and Lyft have abandoned in-house self-driving taxi efforts.
7 days ago
Solar panels might not be affordable for Utahns....
Amanda Dickson

Can the average Utahn afford to go solar?

With power bills going up around the country, more people are investigating the option of going solar. When you add in federal and state incentives, is it affordable for the average Utahn?
8 days ago
Potential Space X debris found in Australia....
Jackie Wattles, CNN Business

Likely debris from a SpaceX capsule found in Australia

NASA confirms that one of the objects is "likely" a scrap of hardware from a SpaceX Dragon capsule that reentered the Earth's atmosphere last May.
11 days ago
AI photos...
Rachel Metz, CNN Business

AI made these stunning images. Here’s why experts are worried

Originally Published: 30 JUN 22 08:12 ET Updated: 02 AUG 22 12:00 ET   (CNN) — A million bears walking on the streets of Hong Kong. A strawberry frog. A cat made out of spaghetti and meatballs. These are just a few of the text descriptions that people have fed to cutting-edge artificial intelligence systems […]
14 days ago
massie grid EV...
Amanda Dickson

Understanding the changing power grid, and that the power comes from us

A solar engineer questions recent public comments by public officials about the strength of the American power grid.
17 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Google v. Oracle court case decided on ‘fair use’