State intends to appeal vacated death sentence of Utah man

Nov 28, 2022, 4:46 PM | Updated: 5:42 pm

death sentence appeal...

FILE: Defense lawyer Mark Moffat, left, clears a spot at the table for death row inmate Douglas Stewart Carter during a hearing in Provo's 4th District Court in October 2007. Photo: Al Hartmann, Salt Lake Tribune/Pool

PROVO, Utah — The state of Utah filed paperwork with the 4th District Court in Provo Monday indicating it intends to appeal the vacated death sentence of a man who has been on the state’s Death Row since 1985. 

Douglas Stewart Carter remains at the Utah State Correction Facility. The ruling that would potentially free him stays on hold pending the state’s appeal. 

Wednesday, Judge Derek P. Pullan issued a ruling overturning Carter’s convictions for the murder of Eva Olesen, whose nephew served as the Provo police chief back in 1985. Monday, prosecutors working in the office of the state attorney general announced their plan to appeal. 

Utah death sentence on appeal since 1985

Carter appealed his initial death sentence in 1985, receiving a second death sentence in 1992. In 2019, the Utah Supreme Court sent the case back to the 4th District Court in Provo. Justices found the testimony of two key witnesses in the case “tainted,” after Carter’s defense team located the couple in 2011. At that time, they told attorneys they had received cash and other gifts in exchange for testifying against Carter in his 1985 trial. 

Back in 1985, Epifanio and Lucia Tovar testified that Carter came to them after Olesen’s murder, bragging about the crime. But in the 2011 affidavit, Epifanio Tovar told the defense he and his wife were advised not to testify about any benefits they received from police, which included rent payments, money for utilities, and even food and Christmas presents, worth thousands of dollars in total.  

The opinion from the state Supreme Court found that evidence could have changed the outcome of Carter’s trial. 

“We hold that there exists a genuine dispute of material fact as to whether the outcome of the trial would have been different,” the justices wrote in 2019. 

Lower court judge overturns conviction

Pullan’s ruling last week cited evidence the Tovars faced threats of deportation and that police coached them on specific language to use in their testimony. Carter’s defense team argued the failure of prosecutors to disclose that information violated Carter’s rights under Brady v. Maryland, a landmark ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court that requires prosecutors to disclose any information that could be considered “exculpatory” — in other words, information that could exonerate someone accused of a crime. 

“The State knowingly failed to disclose that the testimony was false and coached by police,” Pullan wrote. “Carter’s conviction was secured — at least in part — on the basis of this false testimony.” 

In announcing their plans to appeal, attorneys for the state of Utah did not offer any specifics about the arguments they plan to make. But the response means the ruling overturning Carter’s convictions remains on hold while the appeals process moves forward. 

Utah officials last put an inmate to death in 2010. Ronnie Lee Gardner’s execution prompted widespread media attention because he opted to face the firing squad rather than lethal injection. It also sparked ongoing debates about the death penalty as a punishment.  

Related stories: 

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.


The Christmas Box House's Christmas in July campaign is asking for donations, which have lagged beh...

Brian Carlson, KSLTV.com

Christmas Box House desperate for donations

At The Christmas Box House, Christmas in July is their campaign for donations, which have lagged behind this year.

2 hours ago

One man and one woman are dead after an overnight housefire in Pleasant Grove early Wednesday morni...

Devin Oldroyd

Overnight Pleasant Grove housefire kills two people

One man and one woman are dead after an overnight housefire in Pleasant Grove early Wednesday morning. The fire is currently under investigation.

4 hours ago

Temperatures reached record highs this weekend, while many Utahns experienced power outages....

Britt Johnson

Thousands of Utahns left without power amidst record temperatures

22,000 Utahns were without power over the weekend, some for 30 minutes, some for almost ten hours, while temperatures reached record highs.

4 hours ago

A man convicted of defrauding investors in a Utah smartphone scheme will spend nearly five years in...

Tammy Kikuchi

Utah man convicted of fraud for cell phone scheme, must repay $10 million

Chad Leon Sayers was sentenced Monday in Utah's federal court for a cell phone scheme. He will spend nearly five years in prison.

5 hours ago

The Tangent Peak fire is burning in Box Elder County, west of the northern tip of Great Salt Lake. ...

Simone Seikaly

Tangent Peak fire in Utah’s Box Elder County just 10% contained

The Tangent Peak fire in Box Elder County is consuming dry fuels in a location so remote that firefighters are being flown in with their gear.

14 hours ago

FILE: Utah State Aggies head coach Blake Anderson watches the game in Provo on Thursday, Sept. 29, ...

Aimee Cobabe

Head football coach at USU officially responds to firing over Title IX policy

Football coach's written response, provided after accusations of impropriety related to Title IX, is reportedly 70 pages long.

18 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

A young woman smiles while reading the menu at a lakeside restaurant, enjoying the panoramic view o...

Bear Lake Convention & Visitors Bureau

The best restaurants to try in Bear Lake

Save this guide to the best restaurants in Bear Lake when you need to find a place to dine during your next visit.

Female leg stepping on weigh scales. Healthy lifestyle, food and sport concept....

Health Utah

Sustainable weight loss: the science-backed way to achieve it

Learn more about Debbie's weight loss journey with Health Utah, who have a unique weight loss philosophy for success.

Underwater shot of the fisherman holding the fish...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Your Bear Lake fishing guide

Bear Lake offers year-round fishing opportunities. By preparing ahead of time, you might go home with a big catch!

A group of people cut a purple ribbon...


Comcast announces major fiber network expansion in Utah

Comcast's commitment to delivering extensive coverage signifies a monumental leap toward a digitally empowered future for Utahns.

a doctor putting her hand on the chest of her patient...

Intermountain Health

Intermountain nurse-midwives launch new gynecology access clinic

An access clinic launched by Intermountain nurse-midwives provides women with comprehensive gynecology care.

Young couple hugging while a realtor in a suit hands them keys in a new home...

Utah Association of Realtors

Buying a home this spring? Avoid these 5 costly pitfalls

By avoiding these pitfalls when buying a home this spring, you can ensure your investment will be long-lasting and secure.

State intends to appeal vacated death sentence of Utah man