New study from BYU shows praise from teachers has huge impact on children

Jan 30, 2020, 1:15 AM | Updated: 6:22 am
Student engagement...
(Photo by Nate Edwards, provided by BYU)
(Photo by Nate Edwards, provided by BYU)

PROVO – A new study from BYU shows there is an effective way for elementary school teachers to get their students to engage in class… be nicer.  Researchers say they found a direct correlation between a student’s engagement in the classroom and the number of compliments they receive.

Researchers at BYU, Vanderbilt and the University of Kansas observed teachers in 151 classes in 19 schools across Utah, Missouri and Tennessee.  They measured how many compliments a teacher gave and compared that to the amount of reprimands and developed something they call a “praise to reprimand ratio,” or PRR.

“The higher that ratio was, the more praise they gave and the fewer reprimands they gave, the better the student’s behavior was,” says lead author Paul Caldarella.

If a teacher’s PRR was equal on both sides, classroom engagement reached around 60 percent.  However, Caldarella says engagement became noticeably higher when the ratio reached 2:1, and reached nearly 70 percent with a 3:1 ratio.

Of course, there will be times when a teacher has to reprimand a child, but, Caldarella says it’s important that they follow that up with praise as quickly as possible.

“Whatever we reinforce, we tend to see more of that behavior,” he says.

Caldarella says they’re working on other studies to determine how effective negative comments are on children.  He says their initial findings show they might not have any positive benefit, at all.  Even worse, he believes a teacher may accidentally be reinforcing bad behavior with constant reprimands.

“If a student is not getting any interaction with the teacher and the only time they get an interaction is when they do something wrong, they may interpret that as actually better than being ignored by the teachers,” according to Caldarella.

The study was published in Educational Psychology.

Today’s Top Stories


Native American regalia...
Dan Bammes

Bill protecting the right of Native American students to wear traditional regalia at graduation moving through Utah legislature

A bill to protect the right of Native American students to wear traditional tribal regalia at graduation passed a vote in the state Senate.
19 hours ago
school masks...
Paul Nelson

SLC students appear to keep masks on, despite mandate being rescinded

Students in Salt Lake City continued to wear masks Monday, despite a mask mandate no longer in effect.
2 days ago
teacher retaliated...
Eliza Craig

Teacher claims school district retaliated against her after she reported students were sexually harassed

A former teacher filed a lawsuit against the Park City School District for allegedly retaliating after she reported sexual harassment.
2 days ago
New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham signs up to be a volunteer substitute teacher amid staffing ...
Veronica Stracqualursi and Michelle Watson, CNN

New Mexico’s governor signs up to be volunteer substitute teacher amid staffing shortage

New Mexico Governor signs up to be a substitute teacher due to the staffing shortage.
3 days ago
west high burglary...
Eliza Craig

A man has been arrested after breaking into West High School late at night

Police have a suspect in custody for a burglary at West High School. The overnight burglary is still being investigated.
5 days ago
florida discomfort...
Amy Simonson, CNN

Florida bill to shield people from feeling ‘discomfort’ over historic actions by their race, nationality or gender approved by Senate committee

A bill that would prohibit Florida's public schools from making people feel "discomfort" or "guilt" based on their race received its first approval.
6 days ago
New study from BYU shows praise from teachers has huge impact on children