Future of gerrymandering reform bill is unknown, proponents say

Feb 21, 2020, 5:01 PM
utah diverse...
One of the many bills being discussed during the 2023 legislative session is focuses on a concept of school choice and teacher salary. Photo credit: Getty Images.

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah — Utah’s legislature may be looking to repeal the effects of gerrymandering reform in the state, according to proponent group Better Boundaries.

The reform bill, Proposition 4, was passed in the general election of November 2018 with a majority vote of 50.3% in favor and 49.7% against. However, proponents report it’s likely the bill is under threat of repeal.

“This is the literal definition of the fox guarding the henhouse,” said Jeff Wright, GOP co-chair of Better Boundaries. “If the Utah legislature eliminates the core principles of gerrymandering reform, they are missing the point. It’s critical we have an independent commission and a legislature that is required to follow the same ground rules as were decided statewide in 2018.”

What Prop. 4 means for gerrymandering reform

Prop. 4 created the Utah Independent Redistricting Commission, prohibiting both the commission and the Utah Legislature from engaging in partisan gerrymandering and incumbent protection.

The commission is comprised of seven members: a commission chair appointed by the governor, two Republican and two Democrat commissioners appointed by their respective parties, and two unaffiliated commissioners.

The commission states it would intend to “follow common-sense rules” to avoid gerrymandering, acting in a transparent manner. This transparency would be accomplished by allowing the public to submit drawn boundaries on maps for the commission to consider.

Proponent groups worried about possible repeal

However, the group Better Boundaries — which is a proponent of Prop. 4 — says GOP leadership is likely to reject the cores of the gerrymandering reform bill, repealing it altogether, according to a press release sent out Friday.

The group argues the proposition creates a process that keeps lawmakers accountable and strengthens democracy. Better Boundaries reports they met with lawmakers during the 2019 general session to convince them not to repeal the bill, according to the press release.

“After extended discussions over two sessions, it now appears the legislature is dead set on repeal, as they have been unwilling to accept any compromise that preserves Prop 4’s ban on partisan and incumbent-protection gerrymandering,” said Rebecca Chavez-Houck, Executive Director of Protect Better Boundaries, in a press release. “From our discussions with legislative leadership, they are insisting that the law must be changed so that the independent redistricting commission is permitted to recommend gerrymandered maps to the legislature.”

Lawmakers say amendment won’t repeal bill

The sponsor of the bill, Sen. Curtis Bramble, says the bill isn’t necessarily up for repeal. However, he said the proposition presented several provisions that are questionably constitutional.

“So, we began negotiating with Better Boundaries a little over a year ago to see if we can come to a common ground on maintaining a redistricting commission and eliminating those provisions that created constitutional concerns,” Bramble said during a public Utah Senate media meeting.

One of those concerns, Bramble said, was implementing language that doesn’t have set definitions — arguing it makes it difficult for lawmakers to defend their intentions behind supporting the bill.

“We didn’t want […] to require [the commission] to adhere to terms that don’t have a clear definition and are not quantifiable,” he said.

These terms include “gerrymandering” and “incumbent protection” — which Bramble says can’t be universally defined among lawmakers.

Under the amendments of the proposition, Bramble said the Utah Independent Redistricting Commission can choose its own standards for drawing boundaries because of its independence. However, those standards can’t be mandated in the state statute.

They said that while they aren’t set on repealing the reform bill, the option is still on the table. This is because someone could offer a substitute amendment that repeals the entire bill, which could be voted on if there isn’t a consensus, Bramble said.

“There is no repeal,” Bramble said. “We are modifying the statute for the Independent Redistricting Commission.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

Today’s Top Stories

All News

Ike Yospe

KSL NewsRadio employees win Gracie Award

SALT LAKE CITY — KSL NewsRadio host Debbie Dujanovic and producer Caitlyn Johnston have been recognized by the Alliance for Women in Media Foundation as 2023 Gracie Award winners. Their radio special, “Genetics and Genealogy: How to use testing and family history to decode your risk for cancer” won “Best Interview Feature — Talk” in […]
12 hours ago
The U.S. Dept. of Labor assessed nearly $17,000 in penalties to Standard Restaurant and Supply in S...
Logan Stefanich

Utah company with ties to polygamous group cited for violating child labor laws

A federal investigation found the company allowed 22 underage employees to work 40+ hours a week, and to begin work after midnight.
12 hours ago
A timed entry reservation system begins on April 1 at Arches National Park in Moab. And it will con...
Simone Seikaly

Arches visit will require reservation April 1 through October 31, 2023

Reservations will be required to enter Arches every day between the hours of 7 a.m. and 4 p.m, April 1 through October 31, 2023.
12 hours ago
A train hauling ethanol derailed Thursday morning in Raymond, Minnesota, igniting several rail cars...
Tina Burnside and Holly Yan, CNN

Homes evacuated after train carrying ethanol derails, catches fire in Minnesota

Preliminary information suggests 14 of the train's 40 cars were carrying hazardous material according to US officials.
12 hours ago
Emergency responders are seen near a site where two military helicopters crashed Wednesday night du...
The Associated Press

Nine soldiers killed after Army helicopters crash in Kentucky

A statement from Fort Campbell says the HH-60 Black Hawk helicopters, part of the 101st Airborne, crashed around 10 p.m. Wednesday in Trigg County, Kentucky.
12 hours ago
Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin spoke on Capitol Hill on March 29 in support of the Access to AED...
Carma Hassan, CNN

This life-saving medical device isn’t required at all schools. Damar Hamlin wants to help change that

Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin said Wednesday that when he played football as a child, he never thought about CPR or where there might be an automated external defibrillator (AED) nearby.
12 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Cheerful young woman writing an assignment while sitting at desk between two classmates during clas...
BYU EMBA at the Marriott School of Business

Hear it Firsthand: 6 Students Share Their Executive MBA Experience at BYU’s Marriott School of Business

The Executive MBA program at BYU offers great opportunities. Hear experiences straight from students enrolled in the program.
Skier being towed by a rider on a horse. Skijoring....
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Looking for a new winter activity? Try skijoring in Bear Lake

Skijoring is when someone on skis is pulled by a horse, dog, animal, or motor vehicle. The driver leads the skiers through an obstacle course over jumps, hoops, and gates.
Banner with Cervical Cancer Awareness Realistic Ribbon...
Intermountain Health

Five common causes of Cervical Cancer – and what you can do to lower your risk

January is National Cervical Cancer Awareness month and cancer experts at Intermountain Health are working to educate women about cervical cancer.
Kid holding a cisco fish at winterfest...
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Get ready for fun at the 2023 Bear Lake Monster Winterfest

The Bear Lake Monster Winterfest is an annual weekend event jam-packed full of fun activities the whole family can enjoy.
happy friends with sparklers at christmas dinner...

15 easy Christmas dinner ideas

We’ve scoured the web for you and narrowed down a few of our favorite Christmas dinner ideas to make your planning easy.
Spicy Homemade Loaded Taters Tots...

5 Game Day Snacks for the Whole Family (with recipes!)

Try these game day snacks to make watching football at home with your family feel like a special occasion. 
Future of gerrymandering reform bill is unknown, proponents say