Utah judge denies lawsuit giving option for classroom learning

Jan 28, 2021, 2:47 PM | Updated: 6:43 pm
SLCSD lawsuit...
Richard Vyukusengere, left, and his brother, Didace Mahoro, attend school remotely at home in Salt Lake City on Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021. Salt Lake City parents who are suing the Salt Lake City School District are asking for an injunction to allow for an in-person learning option. (Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret News)
(Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret News)

SALT LAKE CITY — A Utah district judge ruled against a lawsuit that would give students an option to go back into the physical classroom in the Salt Lake City School District (SLCSD) through a decision made Thursday. Third District Judge Adam Mow stated the group of parents who filed the suit couldn’t substantially prove students were uniquely disadvantaged from virtual learning. 

Classroom lawsuit finds no direct evidence of harm 

The decision denied a motion for a preliminary injunction by the plaintiffs hoping to reopen SLCSD schools four days a week.  

Specifically, Mow ruled that the 11 parents behind the lawsuit couldn’t prove “irreparable harms” as a direct result of virtual learning. Mow pointed to an argument made by the plaintiffs’ that SLCSD failure rates are increasing during the 2020-2021 school year. 

“They [the plaintiffs’] fail to show any credible evidence regarding whether those rates differ from failure rates in the other 41 school districts in Utah,” Mow said. “Thus, the Court is left to speculate whether the online-only instruction SLCSD offered—rather than other stresses attendant to life during a pandemic—have caused the increase in failure rates in SLCSD.” 

Equal access to education 

Mow ruled it doesn’t violate the student’s constitutional rights to learn solely online because there is equal access to the curriculum offered in both in-person and remote instruction. 

The “plaintiffs’ children are not entitled to a specific modality of education—they are instead entitled to access the curriculum,” Mow wrote. “Plaintiffs’ children are being offered access to curriculum appropriate to their age and development level through the online instruction SLCSD offers. They have not faced a restriction on their access to that curriculum that is not placed on other students in the State.” 
In short, the judge ruled that the parents’ didn’t prove online learning hinders students’ educational development and causing them to fall behind in school. 
Mow also argued that the plaintiffs have the right to enroll their kids in any Utah school district. 
“Plaintiffs have the ability to transfer their children to schools in other districts or charter schools if they disagree with SLCSD’s Restart Plan, as evidenced by the 1,230 students from SLCSD who have already availed themselves of such opportunity during the 2020-2021 school year,” Mow said. 

School districts decide how to teach 

Additionally, Mow gave credence to the school district, citing Utah law that gives SLCSD the power to determine the best way to educate students, especially in the wake of a public health crisis. 
“Under Utah law and Utah State Board of Education guidelines, elected local district school boards have the authority to make that decision for their respective students,” Mow ruled.
However, Mow said even though some students may be struggling, the court cannot intervene in school board decisions. 
“Clearly, some students in Salt Lake City School District have struggled with online instruction, which has resulted in academic, emotional, financial and other issues,” Mow wrote. “But this court’s task is not to determine whether the board made the best decision or to substitute its judgment for that of the board.”

Today’s Top Stories

All News

The Book of Mormon Art Catalog offers users a variety of ways to conduct specific searches and to b...
Devin Oldroyd

Book of Mormon digital visual art catalog launches Monday

A digital catalog of visual art inspired by the Book of Mormon became available on Oct. 3. It features more than 2,000 pieces.
18 hours ago
Mosquitos at a Utah lab are pictured....
Britt Johnson

Uptick in mosquitos in Utah caused by recent weather and temperatures

Mosquitos in Utah have seen a growth in population thanks to recent weather. While aggressive, they are not the disease-carrying breed.
18 hours ago
Arctic Monkeys pictured performing....
Waverly Golden

Arctic Monkeys coming to Salt Lake City in 2023

The Arctic Monkeys, the English rock band, announced their 2023 tour dates and Salt Lake City made the list. 
18 hours ago
Salt Lake County DA Sim Gill...
Simone Seikaly

Salt Lake County DA will not file charges in officer-involved incident

Salt Lake County DA Sim Gill says an incident on March 17, 2022, doesn't fall into the category of an officer-involved critical incident.
18 hours ago
University of utah sign pictured, an assault off campus at a frat house is being investigated...
Becky Bruce

SLCPD investigating reported sexual assault at frat house near University of Utah

An alert went out to University of Utah faculty, staff and students saying the sexual assault happened at the Pi Kappa Alpha frat house.
18 hours ago
The Cottonwood Colts football team  (Courtesy of Deseret News)...
Chandler Holt

Cottonwood High School wins football game in bizarre fashion

There are over 14,000 high school football teams in the United States. Cottonwood High School's game against Jordan had an ending you probably haven't seen before.
18 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Young woman receiving laser treatment...
Form Derm Spa

How facial plastic surgery and skincare are joining forces

Facial plastic surgery is not only about looking good but about feeling good too. The medical team at Form Spa are trained to help you reach your aesthetic outcomes through surgery and through skincare and dermatology, too.
large group of friends tohether in a park having fun...
BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

What differentiates BYU’s MBA program from other MBA programs

Commitment to service is at the heart of BYU’s MBA program, which makes it stand out among other MBA programs across the country.
a worker with a drill in an orange helmet installs a door in the house...
Price's Guaranteed Doors

Home improvement tip: Increase the value of your home by weatherproofing doors

Make sure your home is comfortable before the winter! Seasonal maintenance keeps your home up to date. Read our tips on weatherproofing doors.
Curb Appeal...
Price's Guaranteed Doors

How to have the best of both worlds for your house | Home security and curb appeal

Protect your home and improve its curb appeal with the latest security solutions like beautiful garage doors and increased security systems.
A paper reading IRS, internal revenue service is pictured...
Jordan Wilcox

The best strategies for dealing with IRS tax harassment | You have options!

Learn how to deal with IRS tax harassment. This guide will teach you how to stop IRS phone calls and letters, and how to handle an IRS audit.
spend a day at Bear Lake...
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

You’ll love spending the day at Bear Lake | How to spend a day at Bear Lake

Bear Lake is a place that needs to be experienced. Spend a day at Bear Lake.
Utah judge denies lawsuit giving option for classroom learning