Analyst: Moab Police didn’t follow ‘letter of the law’ during Petito interaction, tried to show compassion

Oct 1, 2021, 6:34 PM
petito body cam...
(Screenshot Moab Police Department)
(Screenshot Moab Police Department)

MOAB, Utah — More body-cam video is being released by the Moab City Police Department about Gabby Petito and the fight she had with Brian Laundrie weeks before she was found dead.  Some analysts say the police didn’t follow Utah state law during that interaction, but they say the situation isn’t as clear as many people think.

Marks on her face

In the newly released video, officers can be seen asking Petito why she had marks on her face and arm.  After tearfully explaining what she and Laundrie had been fighting about, she told officers Laundrie grabbed her by the face.

She said, “He, like, grabbed me like with his nail and I guess that’s why it looks [that way].  I definitely have a cut right here because I can feel it and when I touch it, it burns.”

Analysts say those marks give police enough reason to arrest Laundrie. However, there is a lot more to it than that.  Petito also told officers she instigated the fight.

“Well, to be honest, I definitely hit him first,” she said, adding, “I slapped him in the face.”

Petito would have been arrested

Former Unified Police Department Deputy Chief Chris Bertram says if the officers followed state law, to the letter, Petito would have been arrested, also.

Bertram said, “We have to question why it was that they didn’t arrest both of them under mutual combat of mutual domestic violence [laws].”

Would arresting Petito, booking her into jail and possibly charging her have been the best option?  Bertram says that’s what the officers had to decide in a very short amount of time.  He says, in the end, officers decided to try and resolve the matter as mercifully as they could.

“I think that that’s what they believed they were doing, at that time, was trying to resolve this at the lowest level and not put people into the criminal justice system that may not have needed to be there,” he said.

Use their discretion

According to Bertram, society has been asking police officers to use their discretion and not arrest everyone they can.  He says communities have told law enforcement to be more flexible with certain crimes like drug use and petty theft. And to make judgments that would normally be made by mental health care professionals

Bertram said, “We’ve asked police to be less strict in the last five or six years.”

However, he says there is a tricky balance between compassion and over-bearing policing. It’s something officers have to consider in every scenario.  With the gift of hindsight, Bertram says arresting both Petito and Laundrie would have been the best option.

“The compassion and mercy, they showed, but, again, lawmakers have said that you will and shall arrest, in these cases,” he said.

Bertram also criticized the Moab Police Department for not releasing all of their body-cam evidence and 911 recordings all at once.


Related articles:

Newly released body cam video shows bruises on Gabby Petito’s arm and cheek

National Park Service stonewalls public records in Gabby Petito case

Today’s Top Stories


Emmett Louis Till, 14, with his mother, Mamie Bradley, at home in Chicago. Photo: CNN / TNS/ABACA v...
Nicole Chavez, CNN

Emmett Till’s investigation closed, no justice for his family

Emmett Till's family waited more than 65 years for someone to be held accountable for his murder. This week, their final hope was lost.
12 hours ago
Screengrab of video footage of the scene Monday Dec. 6. Photo:  KSL TV...
Eliza Craig

Child porn investigation leads to meth discovery, closure of Sandy daycare

Police searching for evidence in a child pornography investigation Monday found something else at a Sandy home that houses a daycare: Meth.
12 hours ago
winds may be to blame paraglider9-year-old boy taser swat dog dynamite evacuation shoplifter injury...
Mark Jones

Man stabbed following altercation in Washington City

A southern Utah man suffered a serious stab wound to his arm Monday following a verbal altercation with an ex-girlfriend.
1 day ago
Two police officers are injured in a shootout Dec. 1 in Taylorsville.  Photo courtesy of Jay Hancoc...
Kira Hoffelmeyer

Second officer released from hospital after shooting in West Valley City

A West Valley police officer, wounded in a Dec. 1 shootout, was released from the hospital on Monday.
1 day ago
Gov. Gretchen Whitmer embraces Oakland County Executive Dave Coulter as the two leave flowers and p...
COREY WILLIAMS Associated Press

Third party to probe Oxford High’s actions ahead of shooting

PONTIAC, Mich. (AP) — A third party will investigate events at Oxford High School that occurred before a school shooting that left four students dead and six other students and a teacher wounded, the Michigan district’s superintendent said. Oxford Community Schools Superintendent Tim Throne said in a statement that he called for the outside investigation because parents […]
2 days ago
Ogden car accident...
Mark Jones

Odgen police arrest man after making threats toward his family, police

Ogden police took a man into custody Thursday morning after he made threats toward his family and police.
3 days ago
Analyst: Moab Police didn’t follow ‘letter of the law’ during Petito interaction, tried to show compassion