Ogden Valley officials sue Utah State Tax Commission over property tax issue

OGDEN VALLEY, Weber County — Ogden Valley, the new Weber County city struggling with its 2026-2027 budget, is suing the Utah State Tax Commission, arguing it should be able to implement a property tax hike for the coming fiscal year.

“We strongly believe that this is a case where the new city’s rights and the rights of the residents should be honored. The incorporation process should not leave a city stranded at startup with inadequate funding — the situation we face,” Kay Hoogland, a member of the Ogden Valley City Council, said Monday. “The Utah code grants our city the right to levy and impose property taxes. This shouldn’t be thwarted by administrative regulations.”

Ogden Valley, located in a picturesque area across the Wasatch Mountains east of Ogden, was formally incorporated last January. However, because the city’s certificate of incorporation was issued by state officials on Jan. 2, a day after the Utah State Tax Commission deadline on Jan. 1, commission regulations dictate that Ogden Valley may not implement a tax hike for the fiscal year running from July 1 to June 30 next year.

City officials are mulling a $2.54 million property tax hike for the coming year to cover expected expenses, a 519% jump. But if they can’t pursue the increase because of the missed deadline, they are instead considering implementing a transportation utility fee of $600,000-$900,000 to help cover expected road maintenance costs and reduce spending elsewhere.

Without a tax increase, the city would “have to operate at a skeletal budget level,” Hoogland said. “We are working with Weber County on other options for budget relief and appreciate their assistance in this difficult time.”

City officials are seeking an expedited hearing in the court case, though a date hasn’t been set yet. They’re scheduled to discuss the budget at a public hearing on Tuesday.

Property tax hike or transportation fee?

The tax commission didn’t immediately respond to a query Monday seeking comment on the new lawsuit, filed June 4. But in a message Ogden Valley sent to city residents on Friday, it argues that state law governing the property taxation process should trump tax commission regulations and that city officials should be able to pursue a tax hike.

“The city argues that its rights as a taxing entity, conferred by state code, should not be overridden by administrative regulations,” reads the message. “The city is not asking the court to approve any tax. It is asking to be allowed into the public process the law already requires before any tax can be set.”

City officials originally filed the required paperwork to incorporate Ogden Valley on Dec. 17 last year. A signature was missing on one of the documents, but corrected on Dec. 23.

“The city again requested the certificate issue on Dec. 29, noting the potential tax implications if issued later,” reads the message. “Despite the city’s repeated requests, the certificate (was) issued on Jan. 2, after the holidays.”

As it stands, Ogden Valley — previously governed as an unincorporated area by Weber County commissioners — has the authority to seek $489,519 in property taxes for 2026-2027. However, that falls short of the $3.03 million city leaders say they need to cover expected expenses, a jump of 519%.

The 519% hike, if implemented, would raise the taxes on a homeowner-occupied home worth $672,032 from $58.77 to $364.07, up $305.30. The taxes on a secondary home of the same value would increase from $106.85 to $661.95, up $555.10.

The city’s draft budget document notes that expected sales tax revenues are below projections from a study completed ahead of incorporation during the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to the current situation.

“Those sales tax revenues were temporarily and artificially inflated and did not reflect normal long-term revenue growth. As the city has begun collecting and analyzing actual revenues, several categories are performing below the original projections,” the budget document reads. “At the same time, the feasibility study underestimated the startup expenses of a newly incorporated city. Actual revenue and expenses are both significantly different from projections in the feasibility study, leaving the city with a substantial funding gap.”

The transportation utility fee, the alternative revenue source if city officials can’t implement a property tax hike, would be a monthly fee imposed on Ogden Valley households. “Similar to utility fees for water, sewer or stormwater services, the fee provides a stable and predictable funding source specifically for transportation-related needs,” reads the budget document.

Other reading: Defaced signs and social media attacks during Ogden Valley mayoral race