Salt Lake County DA spars with state officials over conviction integrity bill

Feb 24, 2020, 6:21 PM | Updated: 7:30 pm
Conviction integrity bill SLCO DA Utah AG...
Some of the protesters charged with violating Salt Lake City's curfew will not be prosecuted. (Exterior of the SLCO District Attorney's Office. Credit: Paul Nelson)
(Exterior of the SLCO District Attorney's Office. Credit: Paul Nelson)

SALT LAKE CITY – One of the busiest prosecutors in Utah has harsh words for the Utah Attorney General’s Office about a conviction integrity bill.

House Bill 325 lets county attorneys create a “conviction integrity unit,” or CIU, which examines past criminal convictions. If someone was wrongfully convicted, the CIU can make recommendations about whether the conviction should be vacated or not.

The Utah Attorney General’s office believes the issue needs more research, and that the proposed bill reflects that.

Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill believes the AG’s pushback limits Gill’s ability to vacate the convictions of people wrongly convicted in Utah.

The AG’s office says their concern is far more complicated than that.

Conviction integrity unit

The argument is over House Bill 324.  It lets county attorneys create a “conviction integrity unit,” or CIU, that takes a close look at past convictions.  The CIU can recommend whether the conviction should be vacated if someone was wrongfully convicted.

Gill asserts he has the implied authority to do that, already.  The bill would just write it officially into law.

“This does not create any new powers.  It’s just simply asserting powers that we’ve already had,” Gill said.

A CIU already exists

Gill says he created his own CIU, roughly a year ago.  He assigned legal heavy-hitters to the unit, which include a well-respected trial attorney, a lawyer that worked for the U.S. Attorney’s Office, a man with decades of experience as a defense attorney and a former chief justice for the Utah Supreme Court.

He calls this a “solid group” of legal minds that will be able to find cases where prosecutors made mistakes.

“As public prosecutors, when we examine that, our ethical, moral and legal responsibility is to [set] that innocent person free,” Gill said.

He also said that since his office files charges in the first place, it should be his office that vacates the conviction.  He questions the claims that doing so would impede the AG’s ability to handle appeals.

“When we’ve talked to academics and other people that have been doing this, that list of fears is something that’s just not real,” Gill says.  “The focus really ought to be on doing justice.”

Officials with the Attorney General’s Office say they’re not as opposed to the bill as people may believe.  They issued a statement to KSL saying, “The AG’s Office is optimistic that, with adequate study and planning by those familiar with these issues, HB 324 could be revised in a way that would create conviction integrity units that will serve their intended purpose while preserving the state’s important defenses for federal habeas cases. But as drafted, HB 324 falls short of that mark.”

The Attorney General’s Office responds

The statement also reads that the AG’s office is already responsible for the four ways the state ensures convictions are valid.  Namely:

“First, it handles all appeals of all felony convictions in the state. Utah Code 67-5-1(2).

 Second, after a direct appeal ends, defendants get at least one other chance for a state court to review their conviction. That post-appeal review process happens through the Postconviction Remedies Act, or PCRA. PCRA proceedings “are civil” proceedings, not criminal proceedings. Utah Code 78B-9-102(1)(a). Because the attorney general’s office must “take charge, as attorney, of all civil legal matters in which the state is interested,” Utah Code 67-5-1(2), only the AG’s Office can represent the state in PCRA proceedings. And PCRA proceedings are a defendant’s “sole remedy” for challenging a conviction after a direct appeal ends. Utah Code 78B-9-102(1)(a).

 Third, the AG’s Office represents the state if a defendant asks a federal court to review the constitutionality of his conviction. Utah Code 67-5-1(2). Those federal proceedings are also known as federal habeas corpus review.

 Fourth, the PCRA contains an additional narrow set of remedies to cure extreme miscarriages of justice. Even if they lose on appeal and in PCRA proceedings, defendants can ask a court to declare them factually innocent. Those proceedings occur as outlined in Utah Code 78B-9-401 and the sections following it. Just last September, the Utah Attorney General’s Office stipulated to factual-innocence relief under those provisions for two defendants—Christopher Allen Wickham and David Hawkins—who were prosecuted and convicted in Salt Lake County. The combined statutory payouts to those two defendants for those wrongful convictions will total nearly $1 million.”


SLCO D.A. creates conviction review advisory board

Today’s Top Stories


This June 20, 2017, photo provided by Chris Wonderly shows Hovenweep Castle at Hovenweep National M...
Curt Gresseth

Supreme Court widens state power over tribes. What does it mean for Utah?

The director of the Utah Division of Indian Affairs discusses the recent US Supreme Court ruling and what it means for tribes in Utah.
5 days ago
In this courtroom sketch, Ghislaine Maxwell, right, is seated beside her attorney, Christian Everde...

Ghislaine Maxwell sentenced to 20 years in prison

The sentencing was the culmination of a prosecution that detailed how Epstein and Maxwell flaunted their associations to groom vulnerable girls.
7 days ago
Protesters hold signs and chant at the Utah Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, June 24, 2022, as ...
Curt Gresseth

Utah women’s reproductive-health doctor weighs in on Roe v. Wade ruling

A Salt Lake City doctor who specializes in women's reproductive health care weighs in on the Supreme Court ruling overturning Roe v. Wade.
11 days ago
President Joe Biden speaks at the White House in Washington, Friday, June 24, 2022, after the Supre...

Biden calls abortion ruling ‘a sad day’ for country

He said the court has done what it's never done before in taking away a constitutional right that is so fundamental to so many Americans.
11 days ago
salt lake mayorMendenhall guns...
Curt Gresseth

After NY law is struck down, two Utah experts sound off on gun rights

Two advocates on either side of the gun-control vs. gun rights debate sound off on the Supreme Court's 6-3 ruling to expand the right to carry a firearm in public.
12 days ago
gun rights Utah abortion Boston Christian flag...
JESSICA GRESKO Associated Press

Supreme Court expands gun rights, striking down New York limits

The justices' 6-3 decision is expected to allow more people to legally carry guns on the streets of the nation's largest cities.
12 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Tax Harassment...
Jordan Wilcox

The best strategies for dealing with IRS tax harassment | You have options!

Learn how to deal with IRS tax harassment. This guide will teach you how to stop IRS phone calls and letters, and how to handle an IRS audit.
spend a day at Bear Lake...
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

You’ll love spending the day at Bear Lake | How to spend a day at Bear Lake

Bear Lake is a place that needs to be experienced. Spend a day at Bear Lake.
Curb Appeal...
Price's Guaranteed Doors

How to have the best of both worlds for your house | Home security and curb appeal

Protect your home and improve its curb appeal with the latest security solutions like beautiful garage doors and increased security systems.
Prescription opioids can be disposed of during National Prescription Take Back Day...
Know Your Script

Prescription opioid misuse | How to protect your family from the opioid epidemic

Studies have shown that prescription opioid misuse has increased since COVID-19. So what do you need to know about these opioids?
national heart month...
Intermountain Healthcare

National Heart Month: 5 Lifestyle Changes to Make Today to Keep You Heart Healthy

Heart disease is the leading cause of death for both men and women. One person dies every 36 seconds in the United States from cardiovascular disease
Joseph Smith Memorial Building...
Temple Square

The Joseph Smith Memorial Building is an icon of Salt Lake City | Why hosting an event at this beautiful location will make you a hero this year

Here's why hosting an event at the iconic Joseph Smith Memorial Building in downtown Salt Lake City will make you a hero this year.
Salt Lake County DA spars with state officials over conviction integrity bill