How a rant from a cheerleader could change free speech rights for students

Jun 8, 2021, 7:58 AM
Supreme Court cheerleader speech case snapchat...
FILE - In this April 23, 2021, file photo members of the Supreme Court pose for a group photo at the Supreme Court in Washington. Seated from left are Associate Justice Samuel Alito, Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, Chief Justice John Roberts, Associate Justice Stephen Breyer and Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Standing from left are Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh, Associate Justice Elena Kagan, Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch and Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett. Before the Supreme Court this session is a case involving whether public schools can discipline students over something they say off-campus. (Erin Schaff/The New York Times via AP, Pool, File)
(Erin Schaff/The New York Times via AP, Pool, File)

A case involving a cheerleader upset over failing to make the varsity squad could change the way we think about free speech for American public school students. 

Brandi Levy, then a 14-year-old JV cheerleader in Pennsylvania, took out her anger over the varsity snub with a Snapchat post featuring her raised middle finger and other profanities sent to friends. When her coach caught wind of the Snap, she lost her spot on the JV squad. 

The last major Supreme Court case to address free speech and students came in 1969’s Tinker v. Des Moines. Students sued after the Des Moines Independent Community School District sent students home for wearing arm bands with a peace sign on them during the Vietnam War. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled both students and teachers have a right to free speech at school. 

Tinker does not mean there are no limits on free speech in public schools, however. Students may not disrupt the school environment, though many people may disagree about what disruption means. They also cannot break the rules to make a point, so long as the school’s rules are applied equally. 

US Supreme Court hears arguments in cheerleader speech case

US Supreme Court justices will decide, likely sometime this month, whether school rules apply to off-campus speech.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which represented Mary Beth Tinker in 1969, represents the now-17-year-old Brandi Levy in her case.

Ms. Levy has not been expelled or even suspended from her school.

In oral arguments, Justice Stephen Breyer got to the heart of the matter quickly, wondering whether online swearing, off-campus, should even qualify for school punishment.

“If swearing off-campus did [qualify], my goodness, every school in the country would be doing nothing but punishing,” he said, according to NPR.

Legal analyst on cheerleader speech fight

Greg Skordas, a defense attorney, former prosecutor and legal analyst, joined Debbie Dujanovic to discuss what could become a landmark Supreme Court decision addressing free speech and students for the first time in decades. 

“We’re talking about a public school,” Skordas said. “That’s important to me because the public school is the government. So the First Amendment deals with the government, restricting the person’s ability to have free speech.” 

Most issues concerning free speech and students in the last 15 months involve off-campus behavior. That means student speech includes things like a cheerleader rant on social media or mobile phone, Skordas noted. 

“If this is a private school, we’d be having a different conversation,” Skordas said. “If the school had even had some regulations in effect for their cheer squad, we might be having a different conversation. But she’s just mad. I mean, she’s just really mad. She posts this thing on Snapchat thinking it’s going to disappear in 24 hours, but one of her friends of course screenshots it, so there it is for time and all eternity.”

‘She’s venting against the school’

“Now she’s kicked off the team because she’s posted this profanity laced video to Snapchat, to something like 250 followers, so it’s not like she’s posting it to millions and millions, but 250 didn’t get very far until it gets sent to the school,” Debbie said.

“And importantly, she wasn’t posting something to incite violence at the school, to bully students or another student at the school, to promote drug abuse or something like that,” Skordas said “She’s just angry. She’s venting and venting against the school and cheer and softball and those kinds of things. It’s more of an angry thing. And I think the school’s position was well, it’s not conducive to what we want to do with the school. It’s not the kind of thing that you should be promoting as a cheer member.”

A mom’s viewpoint

Debbie said she approaches the case from her point of view as a mom. 

“I do not want the school to suspend my child, kick my kid off of any team for something that they say on social media . . . I think the school district was way out of line for this,” she said.

“This is way out of bounds. [It] has nothing at all to do with being on campus, in a classroom, posting a Snapchat video about how much you hate the school. This is totally off-campus on a Saturday at a teen hangout. I think the school district’s way out of line,” Debbie said.

“Well, I don’t necessarily agree with you,” Skordas said. “I think there are some limits on this, but I would ask you this, not to put you too much on the spot, but does it matter what the content of her speech was? What if her words had been something different?”

“I’m going to talk specifically to the case,” Debbie said. “This was a profanity-laced Snapchat. She was angry at the cheer squad. It wasn’t a call for violence. She wasn’t bullying anybody — she just hated her school in the moment, she was 14 years old, she can say whatever she wants to on social media. And it’s my decision as a parent to put her in timeout or to ground her.”

Debbie to school district: ‘Pound sand’

“She was taken off the cheer squad. I mean, maybe there’s worse things,” Skordas said. “The school’s  reaction wasn’t over the top. I mean they didn’t say, ‘You’re out of here.'”

“But that cheer squad, Greg, may be her connection to her friends,” Debbie replied. “That age certainly can be a child’s connection to their identity, to their future. If you’ve had a teenager, you know how these things go.

“If they’re kicked off of a team that could create another host of issues. I think in this case the school was clearly wrong. If I were sitting on the Supreme Court, I would absolutely rule in the student’s favor and tell the school district to pound sand,” she said.

“I think most legal experts are going to agree with you,”  Skordas said.

The Supreme Court typically releases decisions on Mondays and Thursdays in June, as its annual term wraps up. A decision in Mahanoy Area School District v. B.L. could come as soon as June 10. 

Dave & Dujanovic can be heard weekdays from 9 a.m. to noon. on KSL NewsRadio. Users can find the show on the KSL NewsRadio website and app, a.s well as Apple Podcasts and Google Play.  

Today’s Top Stories

Dave & Dujanovic

A motorist drives through the snow in Olympus Cove in Salt Lake County. (Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret...
Curt Gresseth

Be Ready Utah: What you need in your emergency winter car kit

After a significant snowfall in northern Utah, are you prepared for a winter emergency while on the roads? Wade Mathews of Utah Division of Emergency Management -- Be Ready Utah joins the shows to give out holidays tips on being prepared for any challenges while driving.
2 days ago
Thanksgiving dinner with all the sides. (Stock photo)...
Alejandro Lucero

Pass the stuffing not the uncomfortable conversation this Thanksgiving

Dave and Dujanovic spoke with an expert who will help you void the gobble-squabble around the dinner table this Thanksgiving.
8 days ago
COLORADO SPRINGS, COLORADO - NOVEMBER 20: People hold a vigil at a makeshift memorial near the Club...
Curt Gresseth

‘I trained for this,’ says veteran who took down gunman at nightclub

A veteran joins the show to provide insight into the actions of another veteran who limited the loss of life at a Colorado nightclub by subduing the gunman until police arrived on scene.
9 days ago
Rioters at the US Capitol...
Curt Gresseth

Utah bill would limit police access to your cellphone data

A spokesman for a a libertarian think tank in Utah discusses why he supports a bill at the Legislature limiting law enforcement access to the cellphone of a person near a crime scene.
10 days ago
rollercoaster lagoon...
Curt Gresseth

Lagoon spokesman explains big price hike for day pass

Lagoon announces Primordial, a new one-of-a-kind interactive rollercoaster, coming in 2023, but with the new ride comes higher season passes.
13 days ago
Police provided an update but added little new information about four University of Idaho students ...
Curt Gresseth

Police stay quiet after quadruple homicide in Idaho

A killer is on the loose, police in Moscow, Idaho, are tight-lipped and a community is on edge after four university students were found slain Saturday.
14 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Happy joyful smiling casual satisfied woman learning and communicates in sign language online using...

The best tools for Deaf and hard-of-hearing workplace success

Here are some of the best resources to make your workplace work better for Deaf and hard-of-hearing employees.
Team supporters celebrating at a tailgate party...

8 Delicious Tailgate Foods That Require Zero Prep Work

In a hurry? These 8 tailgate foods take zero prep work, so you can fuel up and get back to what matters most: getting hyped for your favorite
christmas decorations candles in glass jars with fir on a old wooden table...
Western Nut Company

12 Mason Jar Gift Ideas for the 12 Days of Christmas [with recipes!]

There are so many clever mason jar gift ideas to give something thoughtful to your neighbors or friends. Read our 12 ideas to make your own!
wide shot of Bear Lake with a person on a stand up paddle board...

Pack your bags! Extended stays at Bear Lake await you

Work from here! Read our tips to prepare for your extended stay, whether at Bear Lake or somewhere else nearby.
young boy with hearing aid...

Accommodations for students who are deaf and hard of hearing

These different types of accommodations for students who are deaf and hard of hearing can help them succeed in school.
Young woman receiving laser treatment...
Form Derm Spa

How facial plastic surgery and skincare are joining forces

Facial plastic surgery is not only about looking good but about feeling good too. The medical team at Form Spa are trained to help you reach your aesthetic outcomes through surgery and through skincare and dermatology, too.
How a rant from a cheerleader could change free speech rights for students