Law enforcement expert worries Moab’s investigation into Petito incident may be too narrow

Sep 23, 2021, 7:09 PM | Updated: 7:10 pm
missing Utah gabby petito and brian laundrie...
Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie, as seen in a video posted to their YouTube channel. This is a screen grab of them speaking about their trip to Utah. A Moab investigation has been launched in the city's handling of Petito and Laundrie.

MOAB, Utah  — Did the Moab Police officers follow the law when they released Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie after a domestic disturbance call days before she was found murdered in Wyoming?  Should they have done more to separate the couple, possibly preventing her death?  The city of Moab is launching an investigation into the case, but some law enforcement experts believe the investigation might not be broad enough.

Moab investigation

City officials released a statement announcing the Moab investigation, saying they understand why the media and the public would have serious questions about the domestic disturbance call involving Petito and Laundrie. 

The statement reads, in part, “We understand that individuals can view the same situation in very different ways, and we recognize how the death of Ms. Petito more than two weeks later in Wyoming might lead to speculation, in hindsight, about actions taken during the incident in Moab.”

The statement also says the city is unaware of any breach in police department protocol, but if the investigations finds one, the appropriate steps will be taken.

Significant improvements

Former Salt Lake City Police Chief Chris Burbank says Utah has made significant improvements in state law to protect domestic violence victims.  He says there are reporting requirements which make a well-established paper trail of complaints, so investigators are better able to track a suspected abuser’s history.  He also says there are better arrest requirements that separate a suspected abuser from their victim.

Burbank said, “Not too long ago, when I began my career, often times you would have an officer show up and they would just say, ‘Hey, you two, knock it off,’ and they’d walk away.”

Plus, there are heightened separation requirements and resources like the YWCA offer victims a safe place to stay while the couple is apart.  However, Burbank says those can only go so far.

“The victim can waive that, saying, ‘Nope, I don’t want that.  I’m waiving that,’ so that they can be together,” Burbank said.

Mixed reaction

Moab city officials say their officers have received a mixed reaction from the public, with some people praising their efforts and others saying their actions failed to protect Petito.  Burbank says cases of domestic violence are emotionally complex, making it extremely tricky for police to reach out to people who need help.

“It is such a tragic situation, and we start ‘what iff-ing.’  Did we do the right thing at this moment, at that moment?’” Burbank said.  “You never want to over-emphasize any one given moment.”

Burbank says there have traditionally been problems with investigations into police behavior.  In this case, he believes investigators will focus solely on the facts of this particular interaction and see if the officers were following department policy and state law.  Burbank says looking at any one case will not give law enforcement agencies insight on how officers should behave.  He believes the investigation should focus on several different domestic violence cases to see if the current policies are working, or if they need to be changed.

“This is how you make the organization better, not just appease the call for action at the moment,” Burbank said.


Related articles

Moab plans to investigate police interaction with Gabby Petito, fiancé

Federal arrest warrant issued for Brian Laundrie, FBI also seeking more witnesses

Today’s Top Stories


draper shooting...
Kira Hoffelmeyer

One man dead after shooting in Draper early Thursday morning

The suspect is still at large after a shooting in Draper, and one man is dead after being shot with a gun. Police are still investigating.
16 hours ago
Police tape is pictured. A hit and run in west valley killed a child last night...
Samantha Herrera

Child dies after hit and run in West Valley

An 11-year-old boy has died after a hit and run in West Valley Wednesday night. Police are continuing to investigate.
16 hours ago
Ogden minor bicycle lane driver arrested...
Simone Seikaly

Ogden man jailed, facing counts of the sexual exploitation of a minor

Michael James Welch, age 31, is accused of uploading child pornography that features two children, ages 12 and 5.
2 days ago
Screenshot of American Fork Police attempting to stop a burglary suspect on August 9, 2022. (Sarah ...
Amie Schaeffer

Video shows chaotic scene of American Fork burglary suspect fleeing Walmart parking lot, suspect remains at large

Authorities in American Fork are searching for a man who was involved in a standoff at a Walmart overnight.
2 days ago
Black Lives Matter...
Aimee Cobabe

Man accused of shooting driver during Black Lives Matter protest trying to get case dismissed

A man who allegedly shot a firearm at a vehicle during a Black Lives Matter protest in Provo is attempting to get his court case thrown out.
2 days ago
reckless driving in centerville...
Mark Jones

Centerville man taken into custody for reported reckless driving incident

Centerville police say a 46-year-old man is in custody after an alleged reckless driving incident through Centerville on Tuesday afternoon.
3 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Law enforcement expert worries Moab’s investigation into Petito incident may be too narrow