BALANCE OF POWER: Voters may be last path to curb legislative power

Feb 3, 2022, 7:45 AM
House Speaker Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, presides over the House at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on...
House Speaker Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, presides over the House at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on Thursday, Jan. 27, 2022.

Editor’s note: This is part two of a series on the Balance of Power in the Utah state legislature. Here’s where you can read the first part.

SALT LAKE CITY — Utah’s legislature has now passed a law updating how school districts switch to remote learning, but one part of the law is raising constitutional questions over the state legislature’s powers.

And it may be up to the voters to voice if they’re displeased.

At issue here is the law suspends Test-to-Stay and details how schools now go remote, giving power to the Governor, State Superintendent, Speaker of the House, and Senate President, who together have final say for schools to move online.

Meaning, if one of them disagrees, a school district would not be able to switch to remote learning. 

“There’s a question of form over function,” said former U.S. District Court Judge Paul Cassell now a law professor at the University of Utah School of Law. “In form this looks like a commission… but the function is to essentially give a single legislator, and indeed a prominent legislator, veto power over executive branch action.”

The bill’s sponsor argues Utah’s Supreme Court rulings allow for commissions to have legislators on them and those commissions may even have executive functions, without violating Utah’s Separation of Powers Doctrine.

Serious questions

“I do think the questions here are very serious,” Cassell said. “And should attract a very close scrutiny from the court system.”

But this issue may never see the inside of a courtroom.

“The only way this is going to end up being challenged by a citizen is they are in some school remote operation order that is overturned by virtue of this law. And then at that point, a parent, on behalf of a child that was harmed by that decision, could go to court,” said Cassell.

Governor Spencer Cox could also challenge the legislature, which also seems unlikely. 

“If we value constitutional governance, then a governor should be willing to block a bill not only is it good or bad policy, but because it violates the constitution,” said Adam Brown, Associate Professor of Political Science at Brigham Young University. “And legislators should be willing to vote against a bill even if they like the policy.”

Legislative power

But the Governor and lawmakers seem to be signaling, at least publicly, that there isn’t a constitutional issue here. 

“The legislature has this authority already,” Gov. Cox said last week. “It’s their authority to use.”

On Wednesday, he signed this year’s version of this remote school bill H.B. 183.

The bill’s sponsor, who’s also an attorney, is Sen. Todd Weiler, R-Woods Cross.

“The legislature has its own law firm, we call it the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel,” Weiler said. “The Governor has his own lawyer, and we have the Attorney General’s Office. And all of them have looked at this. We’re getting the advice that this is within the purview of the legislature.”

Not the best bellwether

But Cassell said the legislature’s own lawyers might not be the best bellwether on this issue.

“It would hardly be shocking news to find that that group believes that legislative powers are expansive. It might be a different case if, for example, the Attorney General were to be consulted, or if the courts were to make the ruling,” Cassell said.

According to Cassell, a formal legal opinion from the Utah Attorney General could be significant. However, a spokesman for Sean Reyes’ office said Wednesday they’re “not taking a position on this bill.”

Utah voters may be last path

As of this writing, a challenge through the courts, the Governor, a new bill changing the piece of the law in question, and a formal opinion from Utah’s Attorney General all seem like unlikely scenarios. Which means, Utah voters may be the only check and balance there is on legislative powers. 

And they may need to use a veto power of their own come election day.

Read more:

Today’s Top Stories


A voter drops a ballot into a box at the Salt Lake County Government Center in Salt Lake City on Mo...
Becky Bruce

The Utah primary election is expected to be ‘pretty normal’

Tuesday's primary election in Utah is expected to be about average for a midterm election.
20 hours ago
A voter fills in the ballot on the voting machine during the Election Day voting at Vivint Smart Ho...
Lindsay Aerts

State elections leaders dismiss state lawmakers claims of vote switching

WASATCH COUNTY, Utah — The State Elections Office says all of the state’s voting machines are working correctly ahead of Primary Election Day Tuesday. This comes after Blanding Representative Phil Lyman made claims on social media, that some of the machines were changing people’s votes. Screenshot of Phil Lyman’s social media post. Lyman posted on […]
20 hours ago
thousands turned out to demonstrate their opposition to the Supreme Court's ruling on Roe v. Wade...
Curt Gresseth

Lawmaker seeks to remove felony statute from Utah’s abortion trigger law

A Democratic lawmaker in Utah said she has filed a bill to remove the felony-punishment aspect of Utah's trigger law that went into effect when the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade Friday.
20 hours ago
Protesters hold signs and chant at the Utah Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, June 24, 2022, as ...
Simone Seikaly

Temporary stay issued for Utah’s trigger law

In the lawsuit, Planned Parenthood of Utah names multiple defendants and says Utah's abortion trigger law violates the state constitution.
20 hours ago
U.S. Representative Adam Kinzinger (R-IL) speaks during the fifth of eight planned public hearings ...
Annie Grayer, CNN

January 6 committee unexpectedly adds new hearing for Tuesday

The announcement came as a surprise to many as the committee had said it was not going to resume its hearings until mid-July.
20 hours ago
praying football coach...
JESSICA GRESKO Associated Press

Supreme Court sides with coach who sought to pray after game

The court ruled 6-3 along ideological lines for the coach. The justices said the coach's prayer was protected by the First Amendment.
20 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Tax Harassment...
Jordan Wilcox

The best strategies for dealing with IRS tax harassment | You have options!

Learn how to deal with IRS tax harassment. This guide will teach you how to stop IRS phone calls and letters, and how to handle an IRS audit.
spend a day at Bear Lake...
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

You’ll love spending the day at Bear Lake | How to spend a day at Bear Lake

Bear Lake is a place that needs to be experienced. Spend a day at Bear Lake.
Curb Appeal...
Price's Guaranteed Doors

How to have the best of both worlds for your house | Home security and curb appeal

Protect your home and improve its curb appeal with the latest security solutions like beautiful garage doors and increased security systems.
Prescription opioids can be disposed of during National Prescription Take Back Day...
Know Your Script

Prescription opioid misuse | How to protect your family from the opioid epidemic

Studies have shown that prescription opioid misuse has increased since COVID-19. So what do you need to know about these opioids?
Follow @ikeyospe...

Tax Tuesday: The Most Common Mistakes People Make When Filing Their Taxes

Fortunately, for most average earners, they will not end up owing overpayments received for the Child Tax Credit in 2021.
Follow @ikeyospe...

Tax Tuesday: How will last year’s child tax credits affect you?

Fortunately, for most average earners, they will not end up owing overpayments received for the Child Tax Credit in 2021.
BALANCE OF POWER: Voters may be last path to curb legislative power