Breaking News:

KSL Legal Analyst: Ruling on St. George drag show consistent with law

Jun 21, 2023, 7:53 AM | Updated: 9:31 am

ST. GEORGE, Utah -- U.S. District Judge, David Nuffer, ruled on Friday the city of St. George viola...

St. George City Hall is pictured on Sunday, Oct. 11, 2020. (Ravell Call, Deseret News)

(Ravell Call, Deseret News)

ST. GEORGE, Utah — When U.S. District Judge David Nuffer ruled on Friday that St. George violated the First Amendment by denying a drag show permits, the ruling was consistent with the law said KSL Legal Analyst Greg Sordas.

In his ruling, Nuffer wrote “Public spaces are public spaces … not private spaces. Public spaces are not majority spaces.”

Judge Nuffer ruled the First Amendment ensures all citizens have access to public spaces for public expression. 

The show must go on

KSL legal analyst, Greg Skordas, told Dave and Dujanovic that this ruling is consistent with the law. 

“Events like this can happen,” he said. “And cities can regulate what we call time, place, and manner, but they can’t just ban it altogether.”

Skordas said that cities can determine the day, time, and limitations that organizations must operate within for public events. Some of these limitations are public decency laws and noise levels after curfew. Skordas said Judge Nuffer’s ruling indicated that a drag show didn’t test these limits.

The St. George City Council was concerned the drag show would be too sexual and that the community could find the show offensive, Skordas said. However, he said this is not an acceptable basis to deny a permit. Additionally, Skordas added, there is no evidence that the show would push the boundaries of public decency. 

“You’re presuming the worst without giving these people a fair chance to have their show,” Skordas said. 

These shows are open to the public, but you don’t have to go

Some people within the community were concerned that the drag show was all-age inclusive, and didn’t feel it would be appropriate for children. For that, Skordas provided a solution. 

“Don’t attend it, don’t support it,” he said. “If you’re a citizen of Washington County, and you think, ‘hey, this is not for me, it’s not for my family,’ then keep them away from it.”

“You can make those decisions as a parent and still allow groups to comply with the First Amendment,” he continued, “and still allow the city and city planners to comply with the First Amendment.”

Related: St. George violated 1st Amendment in denying a drag show permit

Why the Southern Utah Drag Stars sued the city

Last month, Mitski Avalōx, CEO of Southern Utah Drag Stars (Drag Stars), filed a lawsuit against the city of St. George for denying the organization a permit to hold a drag show in a city park. Avalōx claimed the city denied the permit because of an advertising ordinance that was rarely — if ever — enforced prior to this case.

Avalox said that, according to the ordinance, advertisement is prohibited until the permit is officially granted. Avalōx said she had been told by a city events coordinator that they could advertise for the event before they had officially received their permit. Despite this, the city later denied the permit.

Nuffer believed this denial was an act of discrimination against the group. 

Related: Southern Utah Drag Stars, ACLU, sue city of St. George

 

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

According to the Utah Department of Transportation, all southbound lanes of Bangerter Highway were ...

Alton Barnhart

Bangerter Highway closed due to weather-related crash, UDOT confirmed

Bangerter Highway closed on Saturday morning due to a weather-related crash over a snowy weekend.

1 hour ago

A long-shot Democratic proposal to raise taxes on those earning $1 million or more was rejected by ...

DANIEL WOODRUFF, KSL TV

Raise taxes on the rich? Utah lawmakers say no

A long-shot Democratic proposal to raise taxes on those earning $1 million or more was rejected by a Utah Senate committee this week.

3 hours ago

This week's freezing temperatures followed by lots of moisture and warmer temperatures could cause ...

Britt Johnson

Recent warmer temperatures could lead to high flooding potential

This week's freezing temperatures followed by lots of moisture and warmer temperatures could cause some flooding.

14 hours ago

Gov. Cox signs union bill into law...

Becky Bruce

Gov. Cox signs union bill into law, despite protests

Gov. Spencer Cox signed HB267, also known as the union bill, which would ban collective bargaining agreements for government employees.

15 hours ago

Multiple groups are saying the federal employee layoffs are likely to have impacts on Utah, especia...

Heather Peterson

Federal employee layoffs likely to impact Utah’s national parks

Multiple groups are saying the federal employee layoffs are likely to have impacts on Utah, especially in the state's national parks.

17 hours ago

FILE - Police Chief Mike Brown and Mayor Erin Mendenhall providing an update on the "Crime Preventi...

MICHAEL HOUCK AND BRIAN CARLSON, KSL TV

Mayor Mendenhall says she forced SLCPD Chief Brown to resign

The mayor of Salt Lake City confirmed that it was her decision to make the city’s police chief step down.

18 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Filing taxes online using a computer...

The Law Offices of Jordan F. Wilcox

Tax time is approaching. What to do if you have debilitating IRS debt

Is the IRS threatening you with wage garnishment, asset seizure or business closure? Here are some ideas to resolve your tax dilemma.

Full speed through the snow. A man on skis is pulled by his through the snow at full gallop Skijori...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Get ready for an unforgettable skijoring adventure in Bear Lake!

“Skijoring the Bear” takes place this year on February 21-22 in Garden City, Utah.

the bedroom in a geodesic dome shows the night sky...

Clear Sky Resorts Bryce Canyon

Your front row to an extraordinary cosmos show

As America's first glass dome stargazing resort, Clear Sky Resorts Bryce Canyon is one of the world’s most unique and spectacular places to stay.

2 people huddled up in a blanket and warm clothes sipping hot chocolate...

Bear Lake Convention & Visitors Bureau

The best ways to spend your Christmas vacation in Bear Lake

If you're dreaming of a white Christmas this year, Bear Lake should definitely be on your radar. Read this guide for more!

big crowd of people under holiday lights in an outdoor market...

Western Nut

Our favorite family Christmas activities in Utah

We gathered up a list of our favorite activities, movies, and treats to try this holiday season that the whole family can enjoy.

an IT tech looks at a laptop in front of a server network...

Comcast Business

Tips to protect yourself from phishing attacks

Check out this resource from Comcast Business to learn more about phishing attacks and how to protect yourself from becoming a victim of one.

KSL Legal Analyst: Ruling on St. George drag show consistent with law