Murray woman arrested for reportedly lying to police about deadly shooting

Oct 15, 2021, 6:42 PM
(Stock photo)...
(Stock photo)
(Stock photo)

MURRAY, Utah — A Murray woman is booked into the Salt Lake County Jail as police say she lied to them multiple times about her boyfriend’s murder.  Investigators say she kept lying even after they showed her evidence proving her statements were false.

Shooting at Murray home

Police were called to a shooting at a Murray home on Sept. 29, where they found Carlos Jhovany Huerta Garcia in the front room with a gunshot wound.  Garcia reportedly died shortly after.  The probable cause statement says his girlfriend, Vanessa Arnold, was home at the time of the shooting.

According to the PC statement, Arnold was interviewed by investigators twice. And in both cases, she told them she and Garcia were in their upstairs bedroom until he went downstairs and was shot by “an unknown suspect.”

However, investigators say surveillance video shows Arnold had been going back and forth between the house and a camper trailer with a man that was later identified as Arnold’s son.  The statement also says her son was seen leaving the house within seconds of the shooting.

It reads, “Vanessa has been interviewed two more separate times since obtaining this footage and continues to deny [her son] was ever present or even that she was outside engaged in any sort of activity possibly related to the homicide.”

Murray woman continued to lie

Investigators say Arnold continued to lie even after they showed her the video.

“Vanessa knowingly gave wrong information about who else was at the residence. First claiming the male who drove the vehicle was named Ismael. And later called the person Israel in a separate interview, not keeping her story straight,” according to the statement.

Obstruction of justice

Arnold was booked for obstruction of justice, and investigators believe she is still in contact with her son.

Former prosecutor Greg Skordas, who is not connected to this case, says obstruction of justice charges don’t always reach the courts. However, police can recommend these charges when someone really impedes their investigation.

“They can also be brought for people that really just went so far out of their way to make the investigation so difficult that they allowed for the police to waste time,” Skordas said.  “They’ll often give an individual an out, and say, ‘Look, if you tell us the truth, we’ll move on.”

Usually, obstruction is a misdemeanor. But Skordas says it can be elevated to a felony if the underlying crime is a serious offense.

He said, “If the police are investigating a homicide, for example, and the individual has obstructed their investigation, that’s much more serious than if the police are investigating a simple drug possession, or something like that.”

Read more:

Today’s Top Stories


winds may be to blame paraglider9-year-old boy taser swat dog dynamite evacuation shoplifter injury...
Mark Jones

Man stabbed following altercation in Washington City

A southern Utah man suffered a serious stab wound to his arm Monday following a verbal altercation with an ex-girlfriend.
1 day ago
Two police officers are injured in a shootout Dec. 1 in Taylorsville.  Photo courtesy of Jay Hancoc...
Kira Hoffelmeyer

Second officer released from hospital after shooting in West Valley City

A West Valley police officer, wounded in a Dec. 1 shootout, was released from the hospital on Monday.
1 day ago
Gov. Gretchen Whitmer embraces Oakland County Executive Dave Coulter as the two leave flowers and p...
COREY WILLIAMS Associated Press

Third party to probe Oxford High’s actions ahead of shooting

PONTIAC, Mich. (AP) — A third party will investigate events at Oxford High School that occurred before a school shooting that left four students dead and six other students and a teacher wounded, the Michigan district’s superintendent said. Oxford Community Schools Superintendent Tim Throne said in a statement that he called for the outside investigation because parents […]
2 days ago
Ogden car accident...
Mark Jones

Odgen police arrest man after making threats toward his family, police

Ogden police took a man into custody Thursday morning after he made threats toward his family and police.
3 days ago
(Getty Images)...
Mark Jones

Tooele County man is taken into custody after child porn investigation

A Tooele County man has been taken into custody after police say they discovered child porn on his computer.
3 days ago
FILE - Ahmad Al Aliwi Alissa, accused of killing 10 people at a Colorado supermarket in March, is l...
The Associated Press

Colorado supermarket shooting suspect incompetent for trial

A judge on Friday ordered 22-year-old Ahmad Al Aliwi Alissa to be treated at the state mental hospital to see if he can be made well enough to face prosecution.
4 days ago
Murray woman arrested for reportedly lying to police about deadly shooting