UTAH DROUGHT

Utah golf courses say they’re reducing water use. Some can prove it.

Apr 11, 2023, 6:59 AM | Updated: 7:04 am

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) Murray Parkway Golf Course on Saturday, April 1, 2023....

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) Murray Parkway Golf Course on Saturday, April 1, 2023.

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune)

This article is published through the Great Salt Lake Collaborative, a solutions journalism initiative that partners news, education and media organizations to help inform people about the plight of the Great Salt Lake—and what can be done to make a difference before it is too late. All of the stories are available on the Great Salt Lake Collaborative website.

SALT LAKE CITY — Golfers say their sport gets a bad rap. Water use data shows some courses conserve better than others.

Utahns rallied in recent years to rip out their lawns or let their turf go brown, motivated by drought, a disappearing Great Salt Lake and dwindling water supplies in the Colorado River Basin.

So when some residents drove past verdant green golf courses, still lush in the thick of summer heat, it stoked their ire. And when a lawmaker floated the idea of requiring golf courses to report their use this year, only to have his bill squashed in committee, it caused some to wonder whether the properties have something to hide. Even John Oliver questioned the logic of Utahns irrigating greens in their dry, desert environment.

Alan Davis, a spokesperson with the Utah Golf Course Superintendent Association, bristles at making golf courses a boogeyman.

“Golf courses were the hero of the pandemic, which I was glad to see,” he said. “It brought record numbers to the game.”

In Salt Lake City alone, golf participation grew by 25% in 2020.

The records received show at least 40 of Utah’s golf courses cut use between 2021 and 2022, despite bone-dry weather conditions. Several courses increased their irrigation — some by millions of gallons.

A private golf course’s perspective

Justin Woodland, superintendent of The Barn Golf Course in Pleasant View, is one of the private property managers who opted not to disclose water use, but he highlighted efforts to conserve.

“We figure we need to be the example in the industry, and we can be,” he said. “We’ve abandoned the driving range. That’s five acres we don’t water at all. We figure if you don’t hit a golf ball off it, we don’t care what it looks like.”

He’s experimenting with hybrid grass species and changing the irrigation system to water a smaller footprint. In 2021, he told the Standard-Examiner he reduced watering by 30-35%.

“We’re spending a lot more money to make the course look a lot worse,” Woodland said.

Dying trees and drying ponds at public courses

Murray Parkway is one of the municipal-owned golf courses that doesn’t track its water use, but it irrigates in a novel way — by collecting water runoff from Interstate 215 along with the groundwater construction of the freeway displaced.

“We get a lot of salts, we get a lot of oils, we get a lot of diesel fuel in the water that isn’t really healthy, especially for ornamentals on the golf course,” golf course superintendent David Carruth said. “That’s a problem we’re willing to take because it saves us a ton of money on water.”

Running all that water through the golf course helps filter out pollutants before they reach the Jordan River, Carruth added.

“It’s surprising how much water it does not take to keep turf alive,” he said. “… And properly maintained turf has a tremendous cooling effect in the summertime.”

Managers of Davis Park and Valley View golf courses, both owned by Davis County, have stopped filling ponds on the golf course and paused irrigation in the roughs, so much so that it’s starting to kill dozens of the courses’ trees, according to golf director Dustin Volk.

“We’re being responsible like the rest of the public,” Volk said, “but that’s been a sacrifice.”

No one has asked for water use data in the 30 years Volk has worked at the county’s golf courses, he said, and it’s not something they follow or track. But information the county and Weber Basin Water Conservancy District provided in a records request show irrigation dropped at Valley View from 137 acre-feet in 2020 to 105 acre-feet last year. Valley View, which covers 183.5 acres, had some of the lowest water applied per acre among the state’s golf courses in 2022. Only Salt Lake City’s Forest Dale and Mountain Dell courses and the Outlaw Golf Club in Hideout used less.

Davis Park, too, has seen significant reductions, using 176 acre-feet in 2022 versus 208 acre-feet in 2021 to water 128 acres.

Asked whether this is the new normal for golf courses, or whether Davis County will return to old irrigation practices now that Utah has seen record-breaking snowpack, Volk said he’ll follow whatever restrictions water managers like Weber Basin impose.

“We clearly want to water enough so trees don’t die,” Volk said.

Making green in Utah’s sunny southwest

In warm Washington County, golf courses use significantly more water than those up north because they operate year-round.

The city of St. George owns four golf courses and provides water to four private ones, though its data is incomplete for the Bloomington Country Club. All its public courses managed to reduce water use in recent years or at least keep it the same, despite worsening drought conditions. The city-owned Sunbrook Golf Club went from using 945 acre-feet in 2020 to 889 in 2021 to 665 last year.

Most of the private golf courses with available data, however, increased their use from 2021 to 2022. Entrada at Snow Canyon County Club used 513 acre-feet in 2022, compared to 376 the year before. That’s because the club’s golf course underwent a major renovation starting in 2020, according to interim general manager Jim Cleary.

“We weren’t running a lot of irrigation,” Cleary said, “… 2021 is a difficult year to use as a comparison.”

The property’s modifications included modern sprinkling and layout systems, which Cleary said will mean “more effective use” of water at the property.

Colby Cowan, director of golf operations for St. George, says the city has also adopted more efficient practices.

“It’s not kicking on water and letting it go wall to wall,” Cowan said. “… We try to be waterwise the best we can, while also making it playable.”

They’ve planted Bermudagrass, a warm-season species with deep roots that tolerate less water. When the grass goes dormant in the winter, Cowan only overseeds the fairways and tee-boxes so they water a smaller area.

“Golf courses, for whatever reason, have had a bad rap on water use,” Cowan said. But he pointed out some of their benefits.

Washington County’s mild weather and golfing greens have lured tourists since the 1960s, St. George News reports. And golf generated a $90 million economic windfall for the county in 2021 alone, according to the Greater Zion Convention and Tourism Office.

“It’s such an economic driver for us down here,” Cowan said.

Who benefits?

There’s no denying golf moves money through Utah’s economy. The Golf Alliance of Utah commissioned a study in 2012, finding golf facilities generated $386 million in economic benefits for the state and created more than 5,000 jobs. It also brought in money through tourism spending, tournaments, capital investments and elevated real estate values for a total economic impact of $806 million.

That was a decade ago. It’s unclear how much more the sport chips in today, given inflation and the boost in participation seen during the pandemic. But all those millions of dollars generated and hundreds of acres irrigated don’t exactly benefit everyone.

Only 250,000 people participated in golf at Utah’s courses in 2021, the Deseret News reported, about 8% of the state’s population. Meanwhile, cities and towns across the state face water shortages, even after a banner snow season.

“If what is happening with respect to tourism is not also equally beneficial to the community that is hosting the tourism, it is not sustainable long term,” said Kelly Bricker, a professor and director of the Hainan-Arizona State University Joint International Tourism College.

For the vast amount of land they cover — 144 acres is the average size of a Utah golf course — only a limited amount of people can be on the properties at any given time.

“You can’t access [golf courses] for other activities like you can parks,” Bricker said, noting she was not speaking on behalf of Arizona State University. “It’s really a very narrow use of that land.”

Golf has also historically been an expensive sport with a high cost of entry. The surge of participation in recent years has improved the diversity of the industry’s participants, but only one in four golfers are women. Only one in five are people of color.

“We’ve talked a lot about … changing the use of golf courses” to be more equitable and inclusive, Bricker said. “Even at night, for stargazing, because they’re in open spaces that typically don’t have light around them. It would be cool, reshaping the perception of what and who they are for.”

In her conversations, however, it’s difficult to get golfers on board with those changes. And it doesn’t solve the environmental concerns golf courses generate, like fertilizers, weed killers and pesticides that wash into streams and lakes. It also doesn’t reduce the resources they consume.

“The amount of water golf courses use typically is horrendous,” Bricker said. “And it does feel very wasteful.”

About 79% of Utah’s available water goes to agriculture, while 9% goes to cities and towns, according to Utah State University. That makes golf courses a relative drop in the context of the state’s water use. But with dwindling supplies leading to a shriveling Great Salt Lake, groundwater depletions and interstate conflict on the Colorado River, conservation of water in cities and golf courses can still go a long way, especially as the population grows.

About 25% of Utah’s 111 operational golf courses either didn’t track their water use or did not share their data. The ones that did provide information collectively used enough water to support up to 50,000 households in Utah a year. That’s more than the number of households in Logan and St. George combined.

“At some point, our environments should dictate to us what it is possible to support — activities, quality of life, all of it,” Bricker said. “I’m sure for some individuals, golf adds to quality of life. But is it something that benefits the entire community and increases quality of life for all?”

For Davis, with the Utah Golf Course Superintendent Association, the pandemic made clear the public benefits of golf courses.

“[Remember] what it provides to a community, what it provides to mental health,” Davis said. “It’s an open space in the middle of the city.”

Great Salt Lake Collaborative intern Emma Keddington contributed to this report.

More from the Great Salt Lake Collaborative

 

 

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

Utah Drought

great salt lake is pictured, a new trust and commissioner for it are on the horizon...

Peter Johnston

Resolution asks municipalities to boost water conservation efforts

A new resolution aims to promote conservation efforts in cities and counties to reduce the impact on farmers.

3 days ago

Brine shrimp...

Amie Schaeffer

Brine shrimp cyst collection at Great Salt Lake up over 50%. Is the berm to thank?

About 29 million pounds of brine shrimp cysts were harvested at the lake this past season, a huge increase from the year before.

6 days ago

Kelby Johnson stands next to a sand filtration system for drip irrigation on his 100-acre farm in B...

Carter Williams, KSL.COM

Utah passes agriculture water optimization measure, weighs another change

A Utah bill tied to agriculture water optimization was passed Wednesday another advanced through a committee.

7 days ago

FILE: Senate President Stuart Adams, R-Layton, presides over the Senate at the Capitol in Salt Lake...

Adam Small

Utah lawmakers advance bill that seeks water sources outside state lines

The bill would create a Water District Water Development Council, which would be charged with looking for new Utah water sources.

10 days ago

Salton Sea dust storm...

Saige Miller, KUER

Lakebed dust is a worry in Utah. For California’s Salton Sea, it’s a full-blown problem

Lakebed dust from the Salton Sea is so bad, residents of Coachella Valley say many of them have asthma or allergies.

10 days ago

Algal bloom dangers...

MIKE ANDERSON, KSL-TV

Dust from Great Salt Lake helps algal blooms thrive, study finds

A new study from the University of Utah shows dust from the lake bed of Great Salt Lake contributes to unhealthy algal blooms.

15 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Mother and cute toddler child in a little fancy wooden cottage, reading a book, drinking tea and en...

Visit Bear Lake

How to find the best winter lodging in Bear Lake, Utah

Winter lodging in Bear Lake can be more limited than in the summer, but with some careful planning you can easily book your next winter trip.

Happy family in winter clothing at the ski resort, winter time, watching at mountains in front of t...

Visit Bear Lake

Ski more for less: Affordable ski resorts near Bear Lake, Utah

Plan your perfect ski getaway in Bear Lake this winter, with pristine slopes, affordable tickets, and breathtaking scenery.

front of the Butch Cassidy museum with a man in a cowboy hat standing in the doorway...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Looking Back: The History of Bear Lake

The history of Bear Lake is full of fascinating stories. At over 250,000 years old, the lake has seen generations of people visit its shores.

silhouette of a family looking over a lake with a bird in the top corner flying...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

8 Fun Activities To Do in Bear Lake Without Getting in the Water

Bear Lake offers plenty of activities for the whole family to enjoy without having to get in the water. Catch 8 of our favorite activities.

Wellsville Mountains in the spring with a pond in the foreground...

Wasatch Property Management

Advantages of Renting Over Owning a Home

Renting allows you to enjoy luxury amenities and low maintenance without the long-term commitment and responsibilities of owning a home.

Clouds over a red rock vista in Hurricane, Utah...

Wasatch Property Management

Why Southern Utah is a Retirement Paradise

Retirement in southern Utah offers plenty of cultural and recreational opportunities. Find out all that this region has to offer.

Utah golf courses say they’re reducing water use. Some can prove it.