Should the public be barred from access to police statements on officer-involved shootings? Both sides weigh in

Feb 23, 2022, 5:36 PM | Updated: Dec 30, 2022, 11:21 am

A votive candle and flowers are left for a teen who was fatally shot at a department store in the N...

A votive candle and flowers are left for a teen who was fatally shot at a department store in the North Hollywood section of Los Angeles on Saturday, Dec. 25, 2021. The coroner's office has identified the 14-year-old girl who was fatally shot by Los Angeles police the day before, when officers fired on an assault suspect and a bullet went through the wall and struck the girl as she was in a clothing store dressing room. (AP Photo/Richard Vogel)

(AP Photo/Richard Vogel)

SALT LAKE CITY — Should police who are being investigated for incidents like officer-involved shootings be protected from making statements that could be used against them criminally? A former Salt Lake City police chief and a law-enforcement advocate share their views.

Why we’re talking about this

This is coming up because of a bill being proposed on Utah’s Capitol Hill. House Bill 399 modifies the list of records that may be classified as protected to include an employee statement given as part of a governmental entity’s investigation into possible wrongdoing, under certain circumstances.

HB399 passed a House committee Friday and now moves forward for consideration by the full House. If the bill becomes law, it would protect Garrity statements from public records requests. Garrity Rights protect public employees from being compelled to incriminate themselves in interviews conducted by their employers during investigations.

The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution declares that the government cannot compel a person to be a witness against themselves, AKA self-incrimination.

Former Salt Lake Police Chief Chris Burbank opposes the bill. But Ian Adams, the executive director of the Utah Fraternal Order of Police, supports the bill. They both spoke to KSL NewsRadio’s Dave Noriega and Debbie Dujanovic about the bill and its implications.

Why a former police officer is against the bill

“An officer can say whatever they want in a police report or in any given statement,” Burbank said. “[Then] say something completely different in Garrity, and we’re never going to have access to what they say in Garrity. [Police Officer Standards and Training] is not going to take their certification away.” 

“So it sounds like you don’t like House Bill 399 in terms of public access being denied,” Dujanovic said.

Should Garrity statements of officer-involved shootings be protected records? Utah bill advances

“We face a crisis of legitimacy and trust with policing in America today. Why would we ever want to conceal information? And again, this is not designed to protect those statements from public access. It’s designed to prevent prosecution,” Burbank said.

Burbank said a case involving deadly force by a police officer is now stalled because the Utah police department involved has withheld information needed by the prosecutor to move forward with the case.

“There is a case currently that exists in this valley in which an officer gave a public statement that is vastly different than what he said under a Garrity investigation or Garrity questioning,” Burbank said. “And the police department has held that information from the public, from the prosecutor so the prosecutor declined to prosecute a case involving deadly force because he did not know the facts.”

For the bill

Adams said HB399 is not a policing bill, adding the legislation was brought forth by the Utah League of Cities and Towns.

“Police officers are just one category of public servants that are affected by [HB399]. And it’s certainly been the focal point of the [news] media,” Adams said.

“What’s the downside or the plus of keeping some of these records difficult or inaccessible?” Noriega asked.

“When the government is your employer, . . . [it] has a duty to manage its workforce and at the same time, protect the constitutional rights of its employees because those employees still have every constitutional right,” Adams said. “They don’t check those rights at the door. What [HB399] doesn’t do is it doesn’t shut down public access to the actual Internal Affairs findings. If there’s misconduct that’s found, that’s still publicly accessible information . . . it wouldn’t be affected by this bill,” he said.

“Would cops, frankly, just stop cooperating if they fear that whatever they said would end up on the front page of the paper?” Noriega asked.

“My sense is that without this bill . . . [police agencies] will constrain these interviews to the point where they’re very frankly pretty useless. I think that’s the response that’s likely to occur,” Adams said.

What are Garrity Rights?

In 1961, the New Jersey attorney general began investigating allegations that traffic tickets were being “fixed” in the townships of Bellmawr and Barrington. The investigation focused on Bellmawr police chief Edward Garrity and five other employees.

When questioned, each was warned that anything they said might be used against them in a criminal proceeding and that they could refuse to answer questions in order to avoid self-incrimination.

However, they were also told that if they refused to answer, they would be terminated. Rather than lose their jobs, they answered the investigators’ questions. Their statements were then used in their prosecutions – over their objections – and they were convicted.

Dave & Dujanovic can be heard weekdays from 9 a.m. to noon. on KSL NewsRadio. Users can find the show on the KSL NewsRadio website and app, as well as Apple Podcasts and Google Play.  

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

Starvation Reservoir body...

Michael Houck

Body of missing man found in Starvation Reservoir, sheriff’s office confirms

According to the Salt Lake County Sheriff's Office the remains recovered from Starvation Reservoir were identified as man who has been missing since 2024.

2 hours ago

Jean-Michel Gisnel cries out while praying with other congregants at the First Haitian Evangelical ...

David Crary, Associated Press

Trump won’t block immigration arrests in houses of worship. Now these 27 religious groups are suing

More than two-dozen Christian and Jewish groups representing millions of Americans filed a lawsuit challenging a Trump administration move allowing immigration agents to make arrests at houses of worship.

2 hours ago

A screenshot from the Utah Avalanche Center website shows the approximate location of the Monte Cri...

Mariah Maynes

Monte Cristo Avalanche report details slide that killed one

A report published by Utah Avalanche Center revealed the details of the Monte Cristo avalanche, which killed one snowmobiler on Feb. 3.

4 hours ago

Water meets the southern shore of Great Salt Lake in Aug. 2024. Grow the Flow is displaying Great S...

Mariah Maynes

New Great Salt Lake billboards show lake’s status

Grow the Flow's new Great Salt Lake billboards were designed to make lake-level data more visible.

5 hours ago

A flag is raised during halftime of the NFL Kendrick Lamar Super Bowl 59 football game between the ...

JON GAMBRELL Associated Press

What’s happening in the Gaza Strip and Sudan that sparked a protest at the Super Bowl halftime show?

A brief protest by a performer at Kendrick Lamar's Super Bowl halftime show unfurled a flag emblazoned with the words Sudan and Gaza.

14 hours ago

SpaceX launched 23 Starlink satellites from California on Feb. 10, 2025. They could be seen from so...

Carlysle Price

SpaceX launch seen soaring across southern Utah

According to SpaceX, 23 Starlink satellites were launched from Vandenberg Space Force Base at approximately 7:09 p.m. Mountain Time.

16 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Full speed through the snow. A man on skis is pulled by his through the snow at full gallop Skijori...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Get ready for an unforgettable skijoring adventure in Bear Lake!

“Skijoring the Bear” takes place this year on February 21-22 in Garden City, Utah.

the bedroom in a geodesic dome shows the night sky...

Clear Sky Resorts Bryce Canyon

Your front row to an extraordinary cosmos show

As America's first glass dome stargazing resort, Clear Sky Resorts Bryce Canyon is one of the world’s most unique and spectacular places to stay.

2 people huddled up in a blanket and warm clothes sipping hot chocolate...

Bear Lake Convention & Visitors Bureau

The best ways to spend your Christmas vacation in Bear Lake

If you're dreaming of a white Christmas this year, Bear Lake should definitely be on your radar. Read this guide for more!

big crowd of people under holiday lights in an outdoor market...

Western Nut

Our favorite family Christmas activities in Utah

We gathered up a list of our favorite activities, movies, and treats to try this holiday season that the whole family can enjoy.

an IT tech looks at a laptop in front of a server network...

Comcast Business

Tips to protect yourself from phishing attacks

Check out this resource from Comcast Business to learn more about phishing attacks and how to protect yourself from becoming a victim of one.

A surprise gift, wrapped and ready to bring holiday cheer! Whether for Christmas, a birthday, or an...

Western Nut

10 Holiday Gift Ideas to cover everyone on your list

This guide is for you if you need holiday gift ideas that will make a lasting impression. 

Should the public be barred from access to police statements on officer-involved shootings? Both sides weigh in