JUSTICE

Parents of Lauren McCluskey officially file second lawsuit against University of Utah

Jun 8, 2020, 6:15 PM | Updated: 9:11 pm
Parents of Lauren McCluskey officially file second lawsuit against University of Utah...
(Matthew and Jill McCluskey. Credit: Kristin Murphy, KSL, file photo)
(Matthew and Jill McCluskey. Credit: Kristin Murphy, KSL, file photo)

SALT LAKE CITY — The family of slain University of Utah student Lauren McCluskey has filed a second lawsuit against the school, this time at the state level.  Attorneys are hopeful the suit can have a major impact on how police agencies are held accountable when they’re found to be negligent.

Lauren McCluskey was murdered on campus in October 2018 after repeated complaints to University of Utah police that she was being stalked, harassed and extorted by an ex-boyfriend. 

What’s in the second lawsuit? 

Among the list of defendants in the latest lawsuit are the state of Utah, former University of Utah Police Chief Dale Brophy, former Sgt. Kory Newbold, former Detective Kayla Dallof and former Officer Miguel Deras.  

Both the federal lawsuit and the state lawsuit argue that the University of Utah failed to provide Lauren McCluskey with the same opportunities and protections they would have provided a male student. However, while the federal suit focuses on Title IX rules, the state lawsuit zeroes in on the Utah constitution’s requirements to provide equal protection. It also accuses the school of negligence and wrongful death. 

The second lawsuit alleges the investigators knew about Melvin Rowland’s threats to McCluskey, and about his history as a convicted sex offender. It also claims the police department acted with “deliberate indifference” when Rowland’s criminal behavior reportedly escalated.

“Lauren and her friends told University officials and police about the abusive behavior and their fears that it could escalate into greater violence,” the suit asserts. “Instead of intervening and protecting Lauren from her killer, the University officials and police ignored, dismissed and avoided her requests for help. They did so based on gender stereotypes and indifference to the risks that women experience when they are suffering from domestic violence.” 

The lawsuit claims campus police demonstrated a pattern of treating women who report abuse, assault or harassment as if they were being investigated for wrongdoing, thus failing to take their claims seriously. 

Hoping for a larger impact

McCluskey family attorney Jim McConkie says the second lawsuit seeks $56 million in damage, the same amount sought in the federal suit. But money isn’t the only thing they’re hoping to get.  The family wants Utah to do away with something known as the doctrine of “sovereign immunity,” which protects state and law enforcement agencies from lawsuits after one of their employees does something wrong.

McConkie says corporations don’t get this kind of protection, and he doesn’t believe police departments should, either.

“If businessmen are required to stand behind the acts of their employees, why shouldn’t the police department be responsible for standing behind the negligence or the bad acts or the mistakes of their employees?” he asked.

McConkie believes this lawsuit could have a ripple effect across the entire country. In his view, unless police agencies are held accountable for their employees’ behavior, the departments have no real incentive to change.

“We think we have a good faith basis to overturning that idea,” McConkie said.

More reaction

However, other attorneys don’t believe this will be an easy legal battle for the McCluskeys.  Former prosecutor Kent Morgan, who is not connected to this case, says the concept of sovereign immunity has been around since the very beginning of this country’s history.

“The concept of immunity is a legal concept that is never going to be overturned.  It would be like saying murder is OK,” Morgan said. 

There are exceptions to this rule, according to Morgan.  He says someone could sue a state entity if their policies violate someone’s constitutional rights.  One example would be if the police agency had a rule specifying they would only arrest people of a certain racial demographic.  Even if the agency doesn’t have that kind of policy in their books, they could be sued if they know one of their employees is breaking those policies without any kind of punishment.

“Does it become a custom or a policy of the police department if the police department doesn’t sanction him for doing that?” he asks.

Officials from the University of Utah say they haven’t had a chance to review the second lawsuit, and won’t comment until they have a chance to do so.

The background of the case

In addition to concerns about whether police took Lauren McCluskey’s concerns seriously are photos her family and McConkie says were improperly accessed and shared by an officer on the case. 

McCluskey had briefly dated Melvin Rowland, 37, in 2018 but ended the relationship after she learned of his true age and his status as a convicted sex offender. She reportedly contacted University of Utah police multiple times about strange text messages which she believed were coming from Rowland’s friends.

McCluskey then received a message demanding that she deposit $1,000 into a bank account. If she did not, she was told that intimate photographs of her and Rowland would be posted on the internet. University of Utah Campus Police Chief Dale Brophy says McCluskey complied with that demand and then reported the extortion to campus police. 

McCluskey’s parents claim former U. Officer Miguel Deras improperly shared the photos, victimizing their daughter a second time. Deras denies the allegations and now works as a police officer in Logan. 

Police say McCluskey was shot to death Oct. 22, 2018 by Rowland. He died by suicide a few hours later as officers sought to arrest him.

Today’s Top Stories

Justice

Protesters hold signs and chant at the Utah Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, June 24, 2022, as ...
Curt Gresseth

Utah women’s reproductive-health doctor weighs in on Roe v. Wade ruling

A Salt Lake City doctor who specializes in women's reproductive health care weighs in on the Supreme Court ruling overturning Roe v. Wade.
2 days ago
President Joe Biden speaks at the White House in Washington, Friday, June 24, 2022, after the Supre...
CHRIS MEGERIAN and ZEKE MILLER

Biden calls abortion ruling ‘a sad day’ for country

He said the court has done what it's never done before in taking away a constitutional right that is so fundamental to so many Americans.
2 days ago
salt lake mayorMendenhall guns...
Curt Gresseth

After NY law is struck down, two Utah experts sound off on gun rights

Two advocates on either side of the gun-control vs. gun rights debate sound off on the Supreme Court's 6-3 ruling to expand the right to carry a firearm in public.
3 days ago
gun rights Utah abortion Boston Christian flag...
JESSICA GRESKO Associated Press

Supreme Court expands gun rights, striking down New York limits

The justices' 6-3 decision is expected to allow more people to legally carry guns on the streets of the nation's largest cities.
3 days ago
Petito lawsuit...
Maria Cartaya, CNN

A Florida judge is expected to make a decision in coming weeks on a lawsuit by Gabby Petito’s parents

Petito, whose disappearance last summer gripped the nation, was found dead in Wyoming after embarking on a cross-country trip with Laundrie, her fiance.
3 days ago
emotional abuse moab police petito domestic violence strangulation gabby petito investigation...
Amie Schaeffer

Wednesday’s hearing in Petito case to determine if suit will move forward

The wrongful death lawsuit in the Gabby Petito case was filed by Petito's parents in March of 2022. A hearing is scheduled for Wednesday.
4 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Tax Harassment...
Jordan Wilcox

The best strategies for dealing with IRS tax harassment | You have options!

Learn how to deal with IRS tax harassment. This guide will teach you how to stop IRS phone calls and letters, and how to handle an IRS audit.
spend a day at Bear Lake...
Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

You’ll love spending the day at Bear Lake | How to spend a day at Bear Lake

Bear Lake is a place that needs to be experienced. Spend a day at Bear Lake.
Curb Appeal...
Price's Guaranteed Doors

How to have the best of both worlds for your house | Home security and curb appeal

Protect your home and improve its curb appeal with the latest security solutions like beautiful garage doors and increased security systems.
Prescription opioids can be disposed of during National Prescription Take Back Day...
Know Your Script

Prescription opioid misuse | How to protect your family from the opioid epidemic

Studies have shown that prescription opioid misuse has increased since COVID-19. So what do you need to know about these opioids?
Follow @ikeyospe...

Tax Tuesday: The Most Common Mistakes People Make When Filing Their Taxes

Fortunately, for most average earners, they will not end up owing overpayments received for the Child Tax Credit in 2021.
Follow @ikeyospe...

Tax Tuesday: How will last year’s child tax credits affect you?

Fortunately, for most average earners, they will not end up owing overpayments received for the Child Tax Credit in 2021.
Parents of Lauren McCluskey officially file second lawsuit against University of Utah