Political fallout from 2020 presidential election looking like 1876

Jul 25, 2022, 5:00 PM | Updated: Nov 8, 2022, 11:36 am

second debate...

In this combination image of two photos showing both President Donald Trump, left, and former Vice President Joe Biden during the first presidential debate Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2020, at Case Western University and Cleveland Clinic, in Cleveland, Ohio. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)

(AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)

SALT LAKE CITY — How was the presidential election of 1876 like 2020’s?

Both saw allegations of voter fraud. Both saw attempts to overturn the election results. The result from these elections remain among the most disputed in US history.

Both also experienced election violence, and disfranchisement of predominately-Republican Black voters.

Texas closes hundreds of polling sites, making it harder for minorities to vote in 2020 election.

Retired University of Utah professor and constitutional law scholar Wayne McCormack shares some more similarities between the two presidential contests held 144 years apart.

Hayes vs. Tilden 

Republican Rutherford B. Hayes was not certified as the winner of the election (winning by one electoral vote, although he received fewer votes than Democrat Samuel Tilden*) until March 2 — 115 days after the Nov. 7 vote and three days before he was inaugurated in Washington, D.C., according to The Washington Post.

Back then, presidents were inaugurated in March, not January. Before the election of 1876, a Republican president — Ulysses Grant — occupied the White House, just like 2020.

Grant, who led Union Armies to victory over the Confederacy in the Civil War, also oversaw Congressional Reconstruction to remove the last vestiges of slavery after the war. Grant declined to seek a third term in 1876.

The 1876 election had the single highest turnout in American history, 81.8%, according to Salon. Whereas the US Census Bureau reported that the 2020 presidential election had the highest voter turnout of the 21st century, 66.8%.

“Before the Southern states sent their electoral votes in for Tilden, they were rejected by Congress on the basis that the Southern states had not been restored to their status as states in the Union,” McCormack said.

The 1876 election also was the second of five U.S. presidential elections in which the winner did not win a plurality of the national popular vote.

“So we had an election that was basically just thrown out in Congress, and Congress picked President Hayes on the compromise,” McCormack said. “The electoral votes were never certified in 1876.”

Dems, Republicans reach a compromise

Initially, Tilden won 184 electoral college votes to Hayes’s 165, with 20 votes from four states unresolved.

The Compromise of 1877 said Democrats would give all 20 contested electoral votes to allow Hayes to become president. But, only if Republicans pulled the last remaining federal troops out of the South. This would officially end the Reconstruction era and abandon Blacks to the racist whims of Southern whites. 

“The end of Reconstruction then went into the Jim Crow laws and the rise of the Ku Klux Klan and the worst of the violent right-wing white supremacists,” McCormack said

Also, in the 1876 election, Oregon’s Democratic Gov. La Fayette Grover disliked that Hayes won his state, as reported by Salon, and tried to offset that by declaring one of the Republican electors ineligible, so he could be replaced with a pro-Tilden Democrat. Sound familiar?

*Like Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton in the 2016 election, Tilden also won the popular vote but lost the election. In that election, candidate Donald Trump also said he would not accept a Clinton victory.


We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

Today’s Top Stories

Election Result

Democrat Katie Hobbs (left) will win Arizona's governor's race, CNN projects, defeating Republican ...

Maeve Reston, CNN

Katie Hobbs will win Arizona governor’s race, CNN projects, defeating Trump favorite Kari Lake

Nearly a week after the election, Arizona Democrat Katie Hobbs will win the Arizona governor's race, CNN projects.

7 months ago

Maeve Reston, CNN

Democrat Mark Kelly will win reelection to US Senate, CNN projects

CNN projects that Arizona Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly will defeat Republican challenger Blake Masters.

7 months ago

The exterior of Orem High School, in Orem, Utah. This is one of the high schools that would have sp...

Simone Seikaly

Orem mayor feeling positive despite failure of Proposition 2

Orem Mayor David Young admits he was disappointed about Proposition 2 failing, but he feels positive about starting the conversation. 

7 months ago

Orem High School from Alpine School District is pictured. alpine school district split debate...

Chris Jacobs

Alpine School District will not split, according to preliminary results

Initial numbers showed that over 70% of voters in Orem chose not to split the Alpine School District to create an Orem Schoo District.

7 months ago

Republican Florida Governor Ron DeSantis celebrates onstage during his 2022 midterm elections night...

Eric Bradner, Dan Merica and Gregory Krieg, CNN

Takeaways from the 2022 midterms: Battle for control of the House and Senate still up in the air

Control of the House and Senate was unknown by Wednesday morning.

7 months ago

open space bond...

Elizabeth Weiler

So far, most Salt Lake County voters have approved the open space bond

The parks, trails, and open spaces bond, according to the Salt Lake City website, will continue to enhance the public lands system.

7 months ago

Sponsored Articles

close up of rose marvel saliva blooms in purple...

Shannon Cavalero

Drought Tolerant Perennials for Utah

The best drought tolerant plants for Utah can handle high elevations, alkaline soils, excessive exposure to wind, and use of secondary water.

Group of cheerful team members high fiving each other...

Visit Bear Lake

How To Plan a Business Retreat in Bear Lake This Spring

Are you wondering how to plan a business retreat this spring? Read our sample itinerary to plan a team getaway to Bear Lake.

Cheerful young woman writing an assignment while sitting at desk between two classmates during clas...

BYU EMBA at the Marriott School of Business

Hear it Firsthand: 6 Students Share Their Executive MBA Experience at BYU’s Marriott School of Business

The Executive MBA program at BYU offers great opportunities. Hear experiences straight from students enrolled in the program.

Skier being towed by a rider on a horse. Skijoring....

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Looking for a New Winter Activity? Try Skijoring in Bear Lake

Skijoring is when someone on skis is pulled by a horse, dog, animal, or motor vehicle. The driver leads the skiers through an obstacle course over jumps, hoops, and gates.

Banner with Cervical Cancer Awareness Realistic Ribbon...

Intermountain Health

Five Common Causes of Cervical Cancer – and What You Can Do to Lower Your Risk

January is National Cervical Cancer Awareness month and cancer experts at Intermountain Health are working to educate women about cervical cancer.

Kid holding a cisco fish at winterfest...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Get Ready for Fun at the 2023 Bear Lake Monster Winterfest

The Bear Lake Monster Winterfest is an annual weekend event jam-packed full of fun activities the whole family can enjoy.

Political fallout from 2020 presidential election looking like 1876