Why finding a special master for the Trump Mar-a-Lago documents won’t be simple

Sep 8, 2022, 8:00 AM

This image contained in a court filing by the Department of Justice on Aug. 30, and redacted by in ...

This image contained in a court filing by the Department of Justice on Aug. 30, 2022, and redacted by in part by the FBI, shows a photo of documents seized during the Aug. 8 search by the FBI of former President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida. The Justice Department says it has uncovered efforts to obstruct its investigation into the discovery of classified records at former President Donald Trump's Florida estate. (Department of Justice via AP)

(Department of Justice via AP)

(CNN) — A federal judge’s move to bring in a special master to review materials seized from former President Donald Trump’s home has opened up an extraordinarily murky, sensitive and high-stakes task of finding an attorney to serve in that role and defining what exactly he or she will do.

The person who US District Judge Aileen Cannon ultimately chooses will have access to documents that have been described as among some of the government’s most sensitive secrets. And they may have very little guidance.

On Friday, the Justice Department and Trump’s lawyers will file legal briefs laying out their proposed candidates, along with recommendations for how the review should proceed.

Cannon issued an order Monday granting a request from Trump that a special master — i.e., an attorney from outside the government — sift through the documents obtained in the FBI’s search of Mar-a-Lago for potentially privileged items.

The Justice Department has previously asked the court to appoint an attorney who already has the top secret security clearance usually required to review the classified materials seized. But that narrows the pool of potential candidates — and finding one acceptable to both sides within that limitation may prove complicated. Outside legal observers have said that a former federal judge might be an ideal candidate, given the experience veterans of the bench often have with dealing with classified materials as well as the reputation of neutrality they’d bring to the role.

But that is only one part of the challenge: What exactly the attorney will be asked to review in the documents for has been left largely unclear by Cannon’s order.

According to the order, the review will include materials covered by executive privilege — a legal gray area that has been perhaps the source of the sharpest contention in the case.

“The problem is the parties will not come to an agreement, because there’s no incentive for either party to agree to the other party’s view,” said Alan Rozenshtein, a former attorney in the DOJ National Security Division who is now a University of Minnesota law school professor.

The Justice Department has called the review “unprecedented.”

“Finding someone to do it is not easy, but not the most difficult thing,” said Jonathan Shaub, a former Justice Department attorney. Shaub told CNN it will be even harder for the parties and the court to hash out what the parameters of the review will be.

“It’s going to be hard for the court, because I don’t think the court understands what executive privilege entails,” added Shaub, now a law professor at the University of Kentucky.

Uncharted legal and political territory

The Justice Department vehemently opposed the appointment of a special master, and it may well still appeal Cannon’s order — in large part because it blocks them from continuing with certain aspects of the criminal investigation into the handling of the documents.

In addition to the attorney-client privilege concerns special masters typically focus on, Cannon said in her Monday order that she was also allowing a review for executive privilege as she said it remains an open legal question whether a former president’s assertions the privilege can overcome the refusal to do so by the current office holder — a matter of fierce disagreement among legal experts.

In this case, President Joe Biden left it up to the National Archives to decide whether it would abide by Trump’s assertions of privilege and the Archives concluded it was not obligated to, according to court filings. Even in the contexts that executive privilege typically comes up — such as in Freedom of Information Act litigation or congressional pursuits for information — there’s much dispute over the breadth of its scope.

Some see it limited as to the communications between a president and his top advisers, while the Justice Department has argued in those kinds of case that it covers all sorts of internal executive branch deliberations as well as attorney-work product and national security privilege.

The Mar-a-Lago case adds in a novel complication because Trump is asking for executive privileged material to be withheld from the executive branch itself.

The special master review will also search for documents protected by attorney-client privilege — a far less unusual order, although typically such reviews are conducted when the office of an attorney has been searched.

This uncharted territory — and what critics say is a vaguely written order by Cannon — has left huge questions about what, exactly, the special master will be looking for once he or she accesses the seized materials.

Both parties are expected to submit by Friday a brief proposing the special master’s “duties and limitations.”

“You know that the Trump team is trying to put a broad scope of review in its version of the appointment order,” Kel McClanahan, a national security lawyer and an adjunct professor at the George Washington University Law School, told CNN.

But if the Justice Department puts forward an extremely narrow argument for what the executive privilege should cover, it risks having those arguments used against it in transparency disputes down the road.

Navigating the security clearance protocols

But the first hurdle is finding a candidate with whom the government feels comfortable sharing some of its most sensitive secrets.

In court filings, it said that if a special master were to review classified material, he or she would need to “already possess a Top Secret/SCI security clearance.”

“We treat [the documents] presumptively as classified. We would not turn them over to somebody that does not have the appropriate clearances,” DOJ attorney Jay Bratt said at a hearing in the case last week.

Trump’s lawyer called the concerns a “bogeyman.”

“If there is a special master that doesn’t have clearance, it can be expedited” by the Department of Justice, Trump attorney Jim Trusty argued. “It doesn’t have to take weeks or months. It can be done very quickly, particularly with a gentle prod from this Court.”

Some legal experts suggested that the government may decide it’s worth forgoing some of the protocols a person would usually have to go through in the interest of getting the special master review started quickly.

Some of the documents picked up in the search may be so sensitive — such as records concerning foreign nuclear capabilities described in a Washington Post report — that it may, counterintuitively, broaden the pool of who the government will find acceptable from a clearance standpoint, according to Rozenshtein.

“It’s almost so sensitive that you’re just going to take a national security risk, no matter who you pick as a special master,” he said, calling it an argument for “just picking someone really respected and renowned because there’s almost no amount of vetting that is going to make this fundamentally appropriate.”

If the judge does decide to choose a special master who already maintains an active Top Secret security clearance, he or she will still need to be given access to the specific program at issue for some of the documents. Some of the documents recovered from Mar-a-Lago contain what is known as “compartmented” information — information that is restricted to a certain group of clearance holders on a need-to-know basis, rather than information that is available to anyone with a Top Secret clearance.

But that process is relatively simple, according to Brad Moss, an attorney who specializes in federal employment and security clearance law.

“This largely can be handled with just some extra paperwork and security briefings,” Moss said in an email to CNN. The special master would be “read on” to specific programs — all work that would need to be done in a secure facility, or SCIF — and then sign briefing acknowledgment forms and likely additional nondisclosure agreements, he said.

The process would get more complicated if the special master doesn’t have an active — or at minimum recent — clearance. Depending on how long ago the Special Master was last “adjudicated” for his or her clearance, the government might require an additional SF-86 form, the standard background check questionnaire national security professionals are required to fill out to obtain their clearances.

Moss said that it is also possible — although unlikely given the limited involvement the special master would have with the documents — that the government may also require a polygraph, as is usually required for someone being granted access to compartmented information.

If the special master has staff helping him or her, they will have to go through the same process.

Finding a candidate acceptable by both sides

A retired judge may be a particularly attractive candidate, several legal experts said, as many veterans of the bench have already had to deal in classified materials as part of the cases they have dealt with. Judges are not necessarily granted a security clearance to do so, but the government may feel comfortable with a retired jurist accessing the materials given that those officials were likely trusted with government secrets when they were on the bench.

“I would imagine there are judges who are qualified, but I can’t imagine it’s a very large pool,” said Daren Firestone, a former DOJ attorney.

Even if the government can be satisfied, the Trump team may not be. Outside observers said the types of recent government exiles who fit the bill from a security clearance standpoint may be seen as objectionable to the Trump team, which has thrown sensational accusations of political bias.

“Ultimately, the potential pool of candidates would likely not be too difficult for the Department of Justice to identify. The issue is going to be which of those candidates would be palatable to the former president’s attorneys,” said Brandon Van Grack, a former attorney in the national security division at the Justice Department.

The choice, in the end, will be Cannon’s.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Send it to the KSL NewsRadio team here.

Politics + Government

Fields in Utah County, near Spanish Fork, on Tuesday, Jan. 30, 2024....

Adam Small

Utah Legislature passes criticized, generational out-of-state water bill

The bill creates a new council with authority to negotiate with nearby states to get more water into Utah.

13 hours ago

president biden shown, he and former president trump are visiting the border in texas...


Biden and Trump touch down in Texas, highlighting immigration as a major election issue

President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump arrived Thursday in Texas, for dueling trips to the U.S.-Mexico border in a sign of how central immigration has become to the 2024 election

14 hours ago

the state capitol is pictured, the utah supreme court is seeking more information about a redistric...

Adam Small

Utah lawmakers pass two school security bills

The Utah Legislature passed two school security bills. One of them deals with concealed carry incentives for teachers.

20 hours ago

A State of Utah emblem is displayed in the Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, Feb. 23, 2024....

Adam Small

Lawmakers pass two bills that could give people big tax breaks

Tax cuts could be on the way for Utahns. Lawmakers passed two bills this week that are now on their way to the governor's desk.

21 hours ago

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) heads to the floor of the Senate for a vote on Capito...

Clare Foran, Morgan Rimmer and Ted Barrett, CNN

Mitch McConnell to step down from GOP leadership position in the Senate

Mitch McConnell will step down as GOP leader in November, the Kentucky Republican announced on the Senate floor Wednesday.

23 hours ago

A photo taken on the Saratoga Springs shore of Utah Lake on August 21, 2021. State lawmakers are co...

Tammy Kikuchi

A bill could improve Utah Lake and get more water into Great Salt Lake

State lawmakers say the goal of SB270 is to improve Utah Lake and direct more water into Great Salt Lake.

1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

Mother and cute toddler child in a little fancy wooden cottage, reading a book, drinking tea and en...

Visit Bear Lake

How to find the best winter lodging in Bear Lake, Utah

Winter lodging in Bear Lake can be more limited than in the summer, but with some careful planning you can easily book your next winter trip.

Happy family in winter clothing at the ski resort, winter time, watching at mountains in front of t...

Visit Bear Lake

Ski more for less: Affordable ski resorts near Bear Lake, Utah

Plan your perfect ski getaway in Bear Lake this winter, with pristine slopes, affordable tickets, and breathtaking scenery.

front of the Butch Cassidy museum with a man in a cowboy hat standing in the doorway...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

Looking Back: The History of Bear Lake

The history of Bear Lake is full of fascinating stories. At over 250,000 years old, the lake has seen generations of people visit its shores.

silhouette of a family looking over a lake with a bird in the top corner flying...

Bear Lake Convention and Visitors Bureau

8 Fun Activities To Do in Bear Lake Without Getting in the Water

Bear Lake offers plenty of activities for the whole family to enjoy without having to get in the water. Catch 8 of our favorite activities.

Wellsville Mountains in the spring with a pond in the foreground...

Wasatch Property Management

Advantages of Renting Over Owning a Home

Renting allows you to enjoy luxury amenities and low maintenance without the long-term commitment and responsibilities of owning a home.

Clouds over a red rock vista in Hurricane, Utah...

Wasatch Property Management

Why Southern Utah is a Retirement Paradise

Retirement in southern Utah offers plenty of cultural and recreational opportunities. Find out all that this region has to offer.

Why finding a special master for the Trump Mar-a-Lago documents won’t be simple