The plan to build an inland port/commerce hub is on hold
Sep 27, 2022, 7:00 PM
(James Wooldridge/ Deseret News)
SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah Inland Port Authority says its plan to build a supply chain logistics facility in Salt Lake City is on hold.
The announcement comes about a week after a state audit suggested that the Utah Inland Port Authority needs a master plan.
“Our sense is, until we really have a good, long-term master plan in place. We want to hold off on any major expenditures,” the port’s Executive Director, Ben Hart, told KSL NewsRadio.
The state audit was conducted by the office of the legislative auditor general for the state of Utah, which summarized its report by saying that the Utah Inland Port Authority (UIPA) must complete its master development plan before any more money is spent on the project.
The need for a master plan
The Utah Legislature created the UIPA in 2018. The legislative auditor general described the UIPA as a “quasi-governmental entity focused on supply chain logistics.”
Of particular concern for the auditors is the exemption UIPA enjoys from many Utah administrative laws and rules.
The legislative auditor general said a solid master plan is essential because the UIPA oversees $150 million in bond proceeds, obtained from public monies.
A best practice of good government is to set clear objectives for the development of a legislatively established program. A plan that defines the ways and means to achieve those objectives should then be established. After reviewing the port’s planning documents provided, we believe UIPA needs to prioritize additional planning, specifically in the form of a master development plan.
Hart told KSL NewsRadio that local communities will have a voice. He said that Salt Lake City and County residents will have a voice in their master plan.
“We have our charge. We know that we have to power local economy,” Hart said. “But we’ve also got to stay focused on helping Utah businesses get their products into the global supply chain.”
The auditor’s review was also critical of the UIPA’s bidding process.
We have documented the port’s procurement policy, which was updated in May 2022. Provisions of the policy that allow for unilateral actions by the purchasing agent disincentivize the use of competitive bidding.
Professor doubts ability of Utah Inland Port Authority to make money
Word that the development was on hold came on the same day as fresh criticism. A business professor from UC Berkeley said the port authority is unlikely to make money. Dr. Robert Leachman said that Utah needs to learn from history.
“If we go back to when goods were made in the midwest and the eastern part of the U.S., instead of the far east, then there was very successful trans-loading at the Freeport Center up by Clearfield,” Leachman said.
“Boxcars of appliances and farm implements would come out, be inventoried here and then re-shipped to all the west coast markets. But there, you’re pooling all the west coast markets and getting all of the inventory efficiencies. The trans-loading makes sense.
“As we converted the midwest and the east into the rust belt, everything was outsourced to the far east. They tried to keep Clearfield going. To work it in reverse direction, to take imports from the far east and distribute them to the west of the U.S. And that effort failed for the same reasons that this (UIPA) wouldn’t work.”
Looking ahead to new thinking, ideas
UIPA Executive Director Ben Hart says that modern thinking and new business practices can help make the UIPA successful.
“People talk about a lot of innovation and great things happening at the Point of the Mountain, but we think we can do some equally innovative, perhaps even some greater things, up here by the lake in the northwest quadrant of Salt Lake City,” Hart said.
Affected communities will impact the master plan, Hart said. But he did not offer a timeline for creating the plan.
Simone Seikaly contributed to this report.